
18/06/2025
TAP Editorial Opinion : Guarding the Flame – Why TDF’s War Narratives Must Wait
In the aftermath of great wars, nations grieve, heroes are remembered, and stories are told. But timing, discretion, and wisdom matter as much as courage. In Tigray today, many TDF veterans and political leaders are racing to write their memories battlefront diaries, reflections on leadership, heroic accounts of resistance. While such efforts are valuable in principle, publishing sensitive operational details while our struggle remains unfinished is a strategic error with historical consequences.
When Memory Becomes a Liability: Lessons from Tigray’s Past
Tigray has walked this road before. After the fall of the Derg regime in 1991, some veterans of the 17-year armed struggle began publishing books and giving speeches detailing their operations. These included maps of liberated zones, tactical insights, command hierarchies, and even vulnerabilities faced in the mountains. What they shared was heartfelt and often inspiring but it was also a goldmine for analysts working for future enemies.
When the genocidal war of 2020–2022 broke out, the Ethiopian and Eritrean regimes applied those lessons ruthlessly. Armed with knowledge from our own post-struggle literature, they:
Blocked traditional supply routes such as the northern corridor to Sudan.
Enforced a total siege based on their awareness of our historical fallback zones.
Disrupted humanitarian operations using insights into local governance and logistics.
Hunted former fighters and informants using indirect identification patterns revealed through past memoirs and tributes.
The result: a complete blockade, mass starvation, and the systematic targeting of civilian and military infrastructure.
This Is Not Just a Tigrayan Problem: Global Experiences Echo the Danger
The perils of premature disclosure are not unique to Tigray. Around the world, resistance movements that exposed too much too early often paid a high price:
The Irish Republican Army (IRA) faced massive infiltration and counterintelligence sabotage after members publicized their operations too openly in memoirs and media interviews in the 1980s and 1990s.
The Palestinian resistance has repeatedly suffered from internal leaks and exposed command structures, which Israel's intelligence services later used to carry out precision strikes and assassinations.
Nelson Mandela, even after the fall of apartheid, insisted on the classification of certain documents related to ANC’s underground structures until national security was fully stabilized.
Tigray must learn from such precedents. A heroic story today can become a weapon in the hands of tomorrow’s enemy.
Tactics Are Not for Public Display Yet.
It is perfectly legitimate to honor the bravery of the fallen, to uplift the spirit of resistance, and to inspire the next generation. But let us never confuse commemoration with confession. Some of the most damaging disclosures currently appearing in public books and speeches include:
Internal TDF command decisions and battlefield deliberations
Descriptions of supply chains and military movement patterns
Intelligence operations and signals breakthroughs
Biographical details of key operatives or informants
Relationships with international facilitators or diaspora channels
Publishing such data today is not historical—it’s a breach of tigray security.
The Nature of Our Adversary Requires Ruthless Information Discipline
Tigray is not dealing with honorable rivals. The regimes in Addis Ababa and Asmara have shown no respect for international law, ceasefire agreements, or even basic human rights. They operate through disinformation, digital surveillance, and regional destabilization. They are known to harvest data from diaspora publications, social media chatter, and even interviews with returning veterans.
Every sentence we publish could be a clue. Every name we mention could become a target.
Strategic Recommendations Guarding Tigray’s Security and Legacy
1. Immediate Moratorium on Military Disclosures
TDF and the interim administration must enforce a publication freeze on all documents that contain tactical, intelligence, or command-level information. This includes books, articles, podcasts, and interviews until conditions are secure.
2. National War Records Review Council
A professional review board should be established to examine all publications related to the war. This body must be composed of retired commanders, intelligence officers, historians, and legal experts. Nothing should go to print without their review.
3. Secure Digital Archives and Oral Testimony Bank
The sacrifices of our fighters deserve to be preserved, but securely. Establish a sealed archive both digital and physical where testimonies, images, recordings, and strategy documents can be stored for deferred release over 15–30 years.
4. Publish Value-Centric Narratives
Encourage authors to focus on why we fought, not how we fought. The values of justice, unity, resistance, and survival are far more inspirational than the details of command chains or troop routes.
5. Mandatory Training on Information Security
Create mandatory workshops for political cadres, journalists, and returning fighters on information sensitivity. Let them understand the invisible line between patriotism and peril, between transparency and betrayal.
6. A Public Campaign: “Write Later, Win First”
Mobilize the public with a slogan-driven awareness campaign “Write Later, Win First.” The idea must be instilled that preserving life and sovereignty is more urgent than preserving legacy prematurely.
Discipline Is the Final Battle
Tigray’s fight is not over. There are still battles to be fought some political, some humanitarian, and some psychological. But victory will not come through firepower alone. It will come through discipline, intelligence, unity and silence when necessary.
We owe it to our martyrs to be wise, not just brave. To preserve the legacy of TDF, we must protect its secrets, safeguard its lessons, and silence our pride until the struggle is truly complete.
There will be a day to tell the full story. But until that day arrives, let us guard the flame not expose it to the wind.