28/07/2022
LAWRENCE WONG MUST MOVE AWAY FROM THE SAME-SAME APPROACH
by
PN Balji
It is a quality that you can’t but admire. The Singapore government has this ability to get its politicians, civil servants, grassroots people and even businessmen and women to put up a show of unity when there is a need to close ranks and sing just one tune. Dissent, especially open dissent, is frowned up.
When PM announced that Lawrence Wong has been picked as the leader of the team that will rule the country, the impression foisted upon the public is that everything is hunky dory. The truth is something else.
Lurking in the announcement are cracks in the narrative that this political succession is not going according to script. First, it is the decision to get the zen-like wise old man, Khaw Boon Wan, to see who in the Cabinet wants who to be the leader. It is clear that the PM had wanted somebody who is generally respected to get the succession going. Khaw was a senior minister and chairman of the ruling PAP. It is a departure from the previous two processes that saw a small group representing the next generation leaders pick their leader.
Second, the decision by PM and his two senior deputies to take themselves out of the decision-making process was not just rare but also strange. Why couldn’t he have followed past practice of getting their own kind to pick their leader, like they did in the past two successions? Even if there was disagreement among the 4G leaders, isn’t it the responsibility of the PM to step in to act?
And Khaw’s involvement in the choice saw an “overwhelming” majority of the Cabinet, including the 4G leaders, choose Lawrence Wong as the leader. But four of the 19 were not for Wong. That shows some kind of open dissent against Wong.
A rock-solid political succession is one of Singapore’s plus points. But this time round, it has been too slow and a little disruptive. The man originally anointed to become the leader, Heng Swee Keat, appeared clueless and confused when he spoke about his East Coast plan after his nomination for the last election in 2020 was announced. Then he threw in the towel after the PM said he was not stepping aside just yet as he felt obliged to hand over power after Covid-19 has been tamed. Heng felt his runway has been cut short. He was already 60.
Now that Wong has been picked as the heir apparent, the question to ask is this: What kind of leader will he be? Does he have the smarts to ride all the rough challenges the new world is throwing up and take the country to a new era.
His biggest test came when he was made co-chair of the Covid task force. With the backing of the entire government machinery and the support of an obedient public, Wong and his team managed to tame Covid.
Bigger tests are on the horizon. Singaporeans will want to know how Wong is going to resolve the sticky problem of foreigners working here. Intellectually, the argument for outsiders to add to the pool is something that cannot be disputed. But emotionally, it is a very divisive issue as many remember how the government went overboard in bringing in foreigners without any consideration for the feeling of Singaporeans. What angered many was the fact that the government, known for its strategic thinking and scenario planning, lifted the floodgates for foreigners without thinking through the after effects like the housing and transport crunch that their entry can cause.
Trust, until then a foreign word in Singapore, began to take root. Twelve years later, the political leadership has yet to shake off this albatross round its neck. One of Wong’s priorities is to retry and restore this trust.
Trust will again be needed as racial polarisation crops up now and then with more and more Singaporeans not being coy to talk about it. There are issues like Chinese privilege, racial divide and the divide between Chinese Singaporeans and Chinese immigrants and Indian Singaporeans and those who come from India. The frustrations Indian Singaporeans have shown against those from India can boil over in no time. Again, it falls on Wong’s shoulders to carry the ground not just with subtlety but with some hard talk on the realities he sees as the PM of the country.
Foreign relations, especially with China, are simmering. Singapore has played a delicate and difficult balancing game between the US and China as the two powers jostle for economic and supremacy. Singaporeans have yet to hear what his views are on this potential time bomb.
Wong’s plate is overflowing. In trying to clear the issues one by one, the one quality he needs is to be his own man. He cannot use the old political playbook and talk about Singapore’s limited talent pool, the dangers of allowing the racial and foreigner divide to boil over and the need for Singapore to manage the China-US economic and security rivalry behind closed doors.
Wong needs an independent streak to manage these fissures. More than that, he needs a rebellious mindset that Lee Kuan Yew showed in the early days.
* This and more on Singapore, get Transition: The Story of PN Balji, in all bookstores now.