10/09/2025
# The Kayan People: Between Photographer's Paradise and "Human Zoo" Through Padaung Eyes
# # Introduction: When Camera Lenses Distort Reality
As an anthropologist who has spent several years with the Padaung community, known to the outside world as the "Long-Neck Karen," I have witnessed the profound contradiction between the images created for tourists and the reality of the people living behind those camera lenses.
The term "Long-Neck Karen" itself is the first symbol of distorted perception, as this community has never called themselves by such a name. They are **Padaung** or **Kayan**, names that connect to their cultural identity and long history—not merely "long necks" as the outside world often limits their meaning to.
# # The Paradox of "Authenticity": When Beauty Becomes a Profession
# # # Voices from Muu Dtae: A Padaung Woman Who Has Seen Both Worlds
Muu Dtae (pseudonym), a 28-year-old woman who once worked in the big city and returned to work in tourism sites, exemplifies the clear contradiction in perspectives on "authenticity." Her experience with the outside world reveals a fascinating reverse reflection.
**The Conversation That Changed Everything:**
During COVID-19, when tourists disappeared, Muu Dtae told me with a tone mixing frustration and irony:
**"I really hate COVID because COVID makes me not beautiful."**
When I probed with curiosity and the familiarity we shared, Muu Dtae explained:
**"COVID was really terrible. No tourists, no income. Had to go back to farming. Couldn't dress up or put on makeup, no time for grooming. Felt ugly, worked hard, and was exhausted."**
# # # A Complete 180-Degree Shift in Perspective
Muu Dtae's response completely destroyed the image of "tribes forced to perform" that many tourists, social scientists, and "critical" anthropologists often interpret.
When I provocatively asked about feeling like "animals in a zoo"—a major issue in academic circles—Muu Dtae and her friends responded with one voice:
**"If we're in a ready state, dressed beautifully, it's no problem because we enjoy being photographed. But we're not comfortable if we're not beautiful yet."**
# # # The Truth That Academics "Think For Them"
What happens is that outsiders, including some academics, interpret and "think for" things that the Padaung people never even considered:
- **Grief from cultural loss** → Reality: Pride in presenting their culture
- **Shame from being stared at** → Reality: Enjoyment in photography when ready
- **Suffering from having to perform** → Reality: Discomfort when not prepared
# # # New Meaning of "Performance"
Muu Dtae and her friends don't see themselves as "victims of tourism" but as **"professional performers"** who take pride in their work.
**"We're like celebrities, actors who have to wake up early to prepare for shows, like artists everywhere."**
Comparable to Taylor Swift who spends hours preparing before taking the stage, or movie stars who dress up before filming.
# # # The Challenging Question: Do You Buy Taylor Swift Concert Tickets?
The final point that Muu Dtae made me realize:
**"Muu Dtae is like a celebrity, like Taylor Swift whom you have to buy tickets to see. Don't you pay money to watch?"**
This question flips the entire perspective, changing from "tribal people being exploited" to "artist performers who deserve compensation."
# # "Human Zoo": The Painful Question
# # # Creating "Performances" for Tourists
At tourist villages, Padaung people must "perform" to be the image tourists want to see:
- **Dressing beautifully at all times**: Even though daily life doesn't require wearing complete traditional accessories
- **Sitting weaving for hours**: For tourists to photograph, even though actual weaving is done at appropriate times and places
- **Smiling and greeting guests**: Even when feeling tired or uncomfortable
- **Forbidden from mentioning suffering or problems**: Because it would destroy the "happiness" image tourists want to see
# # # Voices from Within: "We Are Not Animals in Cages"
**"Sometimes I feel like an animal in a zoo. People come to look, take photos, then leave. But they never ask how we feel."** - Words from Ms. Mali (pseudonym), a 25-year-old Padaung woman
In-depth research reveals complex feelings:
- **Pride in culture**: Mixed with sadness that it's commodified
- **Excitement from meeting new people**: Mixed with exhaustion from having to "perform"
- **Gratitude for income**: Mixed with feelings of lost dignity
- **Hope for a better future**: Mixed with fear of losing identity
# # Reinterpreting Meaning: When the "Studied" Speak Back
# # # From Padaung Perspective: Being "Made Into Folklore"
Padaung people realize they've been made into "folk tales" created by outsiders:
**"They tell our stories, but not the real ones. They say we wear brass rings because we believe it makes us beautiful, but the truth is more complex than that."** - Words from Grandma Sai (pseudonym), an elder in the village
# # # The True Meaning of the Neck Ring Tradition
From in-depth interviews, the real meaning of wearing brass neck rings:
- **Symbol of womanhood**: Coming of age, readiness for marriage
- **Connection to ancestors**: Continuing traditions linked to the spirits of the deceased
- **Protection**: In traditional beliefs, neck rings help protect from spiritual dangers
- **Social status**: Displaying family wealth and position
# # # Negotiating with Modernity
Padaung people are not merely "victims" of tourism but individuals who negotiate and adapt:
**"We have to choose. Sometimes we have to perform what they want to see so our children can go to school, have a better future."** - Words from Elder Somchai (pseudonym)
# # # Survival Strategies
The community has developed several strategies:
1. **Space separation**: Separating tourist areas from private living spaces
2. **Diversified income**: Not relying solely on tourism
3. **Education**: Sending children to school for opportunities
4. **Collective action**: Building networks to negotiate with tourism business owners
# # New Questions for Conscious Tourists
# # # Is "Respectful" Tourism Possible?
Questions to ask yourself before visiting:
1. **What are we going for?** To photograph "exotic" things or to truly learn?
2. **How prepared are we?** Do we know the history, culture, and challenges they face?
3. **How do we interact?** As viewers or as learners?
4. **Where does our money go?** Does the community benefit fairly?
# # # Suggestions for Dignified Tourism
- **Learn before going**: Read books, watch documentaries, learn history
- **Make time worthwhile**: Don't rush to take photos; try conversing, listening to stories
- **Respect boundaries**: Don't photograph without permission, don't enter private areas
- **Support sustainably**: Buy souvenirs made by the community, support education
# # Conclusion: Opening Space for Voices of Those in the Story
This journey as an anthropologist shows us there is no "single truth" in telling community stories. Padaung people are not merely "Long-Neck Karen" as tourists want to see them, but people with feelings, thoughts, dreams, and complex challenges.
What we call "authentic" might become the most "artificial" thing, while the authenticity of life lies in contradictions, adaptations, and struggles to survive in a changing world.
Listening to Padaung voices makes us realize that our roles as tourists, researchers, or even article writers contribute to either building or destroying people's dignity.
The final question we should ask ourselves: Do we want to see the "Long-Neck Karen" as we think they should be, or are we ready to learn about the Padaung as they truly are?
---read more
www.chiamgmaiphototour.com
*This article is written from fieldwork experience, combined with documentary studies and in-depth interviews with Padaung community members. Personal names in the article are pseudonyms to protect privacy.*
