12/10/2025
UPDATED: 'FRAUDULENT' PURCHASE OF CLICO ENERGY SHARES BY PROMAN NEEDS TO BE ADDRESSED IN BUDGET..Because Executing Final Judgement Will Impact On:
●Recovery Of Bailout Repayment
●New Dividend Income Stream
●Economic Growth Depending On If Indigenous CLF Conglomerate Control Is Restored At Clico Energy
By SIEWDATH PERSAD, Editor
PRIME Minister Kamla Persad-Bissessar held high-level energy panchayat with senior officials from Proman, BPTT, and Woodside at the Office of Prime Minister on Thursday October 09.
Notably, the principal Proman representative, who was involved in the discussions, ducked out of a group photo taken after the meeting with Prime Minister Persad-Bissessar.
Also present at the meeting were Attorney General John Jeremie, Energy Minister Dr Roodal Moonilal, Minister in the Ministry of Energy Ernesto Kesar and National Gas Company (NGC) chairman Gerald Ramdeen.
Incidentally, Minister of Finance and Corporation Sole Davendranath Tancoo was not in the picture as evidence of having attended the meeting.
But he would surely have been briefed or given instructions at Thursday's subsequent Cabinet meeting on issues emanating to factor into his budget presentation on Monday (October 13).
According to a statement from the Office of Prime Minister (OPM), the conversations centred around strengthening energy security, attracting new investment, and unlocking fresh opportunities for growth and innovation.
These are nice sounding phrases. But they reveal precious little. It is likely that specific actions or measurable tangible benefits emanating from the talks will be announced during the 2025/2026 Budget presentation or ensuing debate over the coming days.
One big-ticket, big-money issue that begs being addressed in Tancoo's impending budget presentation is Proman's fraudulent purchase of 51 percent shares in Clico Energy from then executive chairman Lawrence Duprey in February 2009, in the midst of negotiating a government bailout agreement.
Duprey had sold CL Financial's (CLF) and Clico's combined 51 percent shares in Clico Energy to Proman for US$46.5 million, without board approval from parent company CLF (now in liquidation).
CLF owns 34 percent and Clico owns 17 percent shares respectively in Clico Energy. Proman held the remaining 49 percent stake at the time of sale/purchase.
CLF and Clico sued Proman. They claimed that the sale was improper because Duprey did not have the authority to make the sale and that the price was grossly undervalued.
In his 2021 Judgement, Justice Devindra Rampersad voided the sale and ruled that Duprey acted "oppressively and prejudicially".
Justice Rampersad ordered Proman to return ownership of the shares to CLF and Clico and pay parent company CLF the dividends it collected (with interest).
He also ordered CLF to reimburse Proman the purchase price plus interest.
Proman appealed the High Court's judgement. In 2023, a three-judge panel comprising Justices of Appeal Alice Yorke-Soo Hon, Gregory Smith and Vasheist Kokaram upheld Justice Rampersad's High Court decision, and made a further ruling that the transaction involved fraud.
Proman sought and was granted leave in early 2024 to challenge the Court of Appeal's decision in the Privy Council.
Proman was ordered to deposit dividend payments up to August 2024 into an escrow account pending the outcome of the case. It had deposited US$193 million, according to the most recent Liquidator Report.
As far as the public record shows, no Privy Council appeal is listed in respect of this matter.
However, Head of External Communications & Government Relations at Proman AG, David Hart, has stated via email that Proman had filed an appeal to the Privy Council in March 2024.
He said the company is yet to be informed by the Privy Council when the case will be heard.
The CLF liquidator has a fiduciary responsibility to ensure that Proman complies with applicable court Orders.
It appears, though, that he is more invested in dissipating and seeking to sell off other CLF assets at fire sale prices to financiers, friends and family of the former People's National Movement (PNM) government. (Click links below for related stories).
The government, as creditor, also has a definite interest in recovering taxpayers' bailout loan extended to CLF.
Besides, the government also holds stakes in CLF and Clico via shares acquired in loan reduction swaps.
These are solid reasons why Tancoo needs to pronounce on steps to bring closure to the illegal Proman purchase of CLF/Clico shares in Clico Energy, because that would have direct bearings on increasing the state's capacity to earn additional revenues in valuable US Dollars.
Other beneficial shareholders are also anxious for a comprehensive update on the status of affairs at CLF, which has been shrouded in secrecy under the connivance of former Finance Minister and Corporation Sole Colm Imbert and sidekick liquidator Mark Byers.
Shareholders are also anxious to see if the government, as creditor, will pivot away from the corrupted liquidation route adopted by the previous PNM administration, by returning to a prefered shareholders agreement intimated by Persad-Bissessar.
The latter is widely considered as a more sensible mode of moving forward in the mutual interest of all shareholding parties and in a manner to stimulate sustainable economic growth, since optimization of operating assets has been stymied under the liquidator.
It will be a travesty of justice if, in his budget presentation, Tancoo does not also comprehensively address the critical issue of reconstituting the Clico Energy board (now known as Process Energy Trinidad Limited) to reflect a majority of CLF and Clico directors as per their 51 percent ownership stake in the company in accordance with the applicable court order.
The population will be watching with hawks' eyes at the new Kamla Persad-Bissessar administration's first budget since recapturing power following the April 28, 2025 general elections.
It will define whether action speaks louder than words in more ways than one.
CLICK LINKS BELOW FOR RELATED STORIES:
https://www.facebook.com/share/p/1CWMkBvhzW/
https://www.facebook.com/share/p/1GuMqbg4VV/
https://www.facebook.com/share/p/1A2CG3tpxX/