Dejavu Crime Crew

07/13/2025

Share, share, share!! Tips on vehicle can lead to this young girl's safe return!!

07/13/2025

ABDUCTED: It has been reported by law enforcement in Idaho that a 12-year-old girl has been abducted by two adult Hispanic men. She disappeared from her home on Saturday night.
The vehicle had 2 suspects and the girl was seen in the back seat according to the officer who made the stop (note: she had not been reported missing at the time of the traffic stop). The vehicle has Texas license plates!!

The following is a news release from the Idaho Falls Police Department. IDAHO FALLS — The Idaho Falls Police Department is searching for Tatiana Fuentes, a 12-year-old girl, who is believed to have left home in the middle of the night with two adult men. Tatiana was last seen at her home the night...

07/13/2025

On Friday, July 11th in Virginia the Mathews County Sheriff's Office 911 Center received a call regarding a structure fire in the 17000 block of John Clayton Memorial Highway. The Mathews County Sheriff's Office along with Mathews County Fire and Rescue responded to the scene and observed the front of a residential structure showing flames. Mathews County Fire and Rescue battled the blaze and made emergency entry into the home. Two individuals were located and pulled from the fire. Both were pronounced dead at the scene. A male victim was identified as 54-year old Chad Wayne Ashford. A female victim was identified as 56-year old Audrey Elaine Hudgins Mowrar. The Mathews County Sheriff's Office contacted the Virginia State Police Criminal Investigations Division who assisted with processing the scene. Investigators observed multiple suspected gunshot wounds to the bodies of both decedents.

Public assistance, digital evidence, and the Flock License Plate Readers ultimately led Mathews County Sheriff's Office to the City of Newport News to pursue leads and a suspect vehicle. Two suspects were located and Newport News Police initiated a traffic stop. The suspects fled on foot, however they were eventually detained. The suspects have been identified as Miss Lacey Ann Horsley, an 18-year old from Gloucester County and Mr. Carol Paul Cormier Jr., a 33-year old from Mathews County.

The investigation revealed both victims were shot and killed on Thursday, July 10, 2025 and the two suspects fled the scene. Then both suspects returned to the scene on Friday, July 11, 2025 with the plan to burn the house down to get rid of the evidence. Investigators were able to recover the vehicle that was used in commission of the crime with assistance from the Newport News Police Department. With assistance from K9 Lycan from the Gloucester County Sheriff's Office, additional evidence was located in Gloucester Point.

The following arrests have been made:

Lacey Ann Horsley
§ 18.2-19: Acting as an accessory after the fact in the murder of Chad Ashford on 7/10/2025.
§ 18.2-19: Acting as an accessory after the fact in the murder of Audrey Hudgins Mowrar on 7/10/2025.
§ 18.2-22/18.2-77 Conspiracy to burn/destroy a residential home.

Carol Paul Cormier
§ 18.2-32: Second Degree Murder of Chad Ashford on 7/10/2025
§ 18.2-32: Second Degree Murder of Audrey Hudgins Mowearon 7/10/2025
§ 18.2-53.1: Use of a Firearm in the Commission of the Murder of Chad Ashford on 7/10/2025
§ 18.2-53.1: Use of a Firearm in the Commission of the Murder of Audrey Hudgins on 7/10/2025
§ 18.2-308.2: Possession of a Firearm by a Convicted Felon
§ 18.2-77: Burning or Destroying the residential home on 7/11/2025

Both suspects are being held without bond and have been transported to the Middle Peninsula Regional Security Center.

07/13/2025

Karen Read lands lucrative book deal while witnesses face continued harassment after acquittal...

After Karen Read's acquittal in John O'Keefe's death, witnesses face harassment, investigators lose jobs, and Read secures media deals while facing a lawsuit.

07/13/2025

What are you binging? I'm currently wrapping up Season 5 of Blindspot. It's about a team of FBI agents and stopping lots of crimes many of which come from decoding Jane Doe's numerous body tattoos. Have you watched it?

We were thinking at one point about creating a group related to podcasting, true crime books, and movie and/or documentary recommendations. Any thoughts or feedback? Maybe fall/winter idea when folks are home more?! Please comment!! We'd love to hear from you!!

07/13/2025

Local to us... the "full 5 minute video" circulating on social media of this incident is very disturbing... today, a peaceful protest will take place at a park in close proximity to the Haverhill Police Department...IMO the autopsy will be a defining factor here when manner of death is determined... the Mayor has promised transparency. She stated a full investigation is being conducted on Francis Gigliotti's untimely death. We will be following this as more details come forth...

A man was pronounced dead after a chaotic struggle with police in Haverhill, Massachusetts, the Essex County District Attorney's Office and Haverhill police department confirmed.

07/13/2025

Hank Brennan, the Special Prosecutor in the 2nd Karen Read trial, raked in 566k!!

07/13/2025

Say what?! Casey Anthony is in New Hampshire? Get out. No literally, I mean get tf out!!!

The infamous Casey Anthony who was gained a lot of attention in the trial of a young child's death is apparently visiting or has moved to Manchester

TMZ article and photo -
https://www.tmz.com/2025/07/10/casey-anthony-spotted-on-date-in-new-hampshire/

07/13/2025

Thank you Shay McAllister for your coverage in the Crystal Rogers case! We look forward to hopefully seeing you soon in your next journalist venture!!

07/12/2025

Have you been following the case of James Craig, the Colorado dentist accused of killing his wife, Angela?

We are!!! Jury selection began Thursday. Link to group 👇

James Toliver Craig Dentist Poison Murder Trial

It was March 2023 when Angela began complaining of severe headaches and dizziness. She had been to the hospital three times in 10 days, yet doctors couldn’t explain what was wrong.

“I feel drugged,” she texted her husband during her first hospitalization. She told him the only thing she consumed that morning was her protein shake, according to court records.

Three hours into her third hospital visit, the mother of six began seizing and was transferred to the ICU. Three days later, Angela was declared brain dead. She was 43.

More than two years after her death, James is due to stand trial for her murder. Jury selection began Thursday.

Evidence compiled against James includes witness accounts, screenshots of text messages and computer search histories, and the discovery of a secret email account used to order a multitude of poisons and carry out an affair with another woman.

Over the past two years, he has cycled through a carousel of lawyers – including one who withdrew due to James' alleged actions and another accused of setting fire to his own home – and the dentist himself has been accused of plotting a jailhouse murder against the case’s lead investigator.

James has pleaded not guilty to six felony charges, including first-degree murder, solicitation to commit first-degree murder, solicitation to commit tampering with physical evidence, and solicitation to commit perjury.

07/10/2025

A man facing multiple murder charges appeared in court yeaterday. He is being held without bond.

Benjamin Roy Naylor, 56, is charged with four counts of first-degree murder after he allegedly killed four people in Cassia and Minidoka counties.

Naylor was apprehended on Tuesday during a traffic stop conducted by the Lincoln County Sheriff’s Office with assistance from the Idaho State Police.

Officers received a 911 call earlier that afternoon from someone who discovered a woman on the floor of a Rupert home who was “cold to the touch,” according to a Rupert Police Department Facebook post. Within hours, two additional homicide victims were located in Cassia County, and a fourth victim was later found in a vehicle in Minidoka County.

The arrest followed a coordinated investigation involving the Rupert Police Department, Minidoka County Sheriff’s Office, Cassia County Sheriff’s Office, Lincoln County Sheriff’s Office, Heyburn Police Department, Twin Falls County Sheriff’s Office and Idaho State Police.

A state public defender has been appointed to represent Naylor in both the Cassia and Minidoka cases. Additional information about the alleged crimes is limited as the criminal complaint and probable cause documents were sealed as of Wednesday afternoon.

A preliminary hearing for Naylor will be held in Cassia County on July 18 and in Minidoka County on July 23.

07/10/2025

Anyone following the Heather Turner case?

Paulding County officials say the investigation into Heather Turner's 2017 death remains open, with key forensic tests still pending before any further conclusions are made.