Crime of the Truest Kind Podcast

12/09/2025

🚨Missing from Mattapan.
Kaleah Bailey-Cannady, age 16
Last Seen: November 22, 2025

Missing Person Information
𝐓𝐞𝐞𝐧 𝐦𝐢𝐬𝐬𝐢𝐧𝐠 𝐟𝐫𝐨𝐦 𝐌𝐚𝐭𝐭𝐚𝐩𝐚𝐧 𝐬𝐢𝐧𝐜𝐞 𝐍𝐨𝐯𝐞𝐦𝐛𝐞𝐫
Kaleah Bailey-Cannady
📍 Location: Mattapan, MA
📅 Last Seen: November 22, 2025
👤 Age: 16
📏 Height: 5'1"
⚖ Weight: 110
• Wearing a black jacket and pink pants at the time of disappearance.
• Last seen in the area of Rugby Road, Mattapan.
• Frequents the area of Spencer Street, Dorchester.
Kaleah Bailey-Cannady was last seen on November 22, 2025, at 5:00 PM, in the area of Rugby Road, Mattapan. She was wearing a black jacket and pink pants at the time. Kaleah is known to frequent the area of Spencer Street, Dorchester.

📞 If you have any information, please contact the Boston PD at 617-343-5607

We verify and post only official missing person cases. All missing posted are added to our database, the nation's largest interactive missing person database

Kaleah Bailey-Cannady database entry https://www.missingpeopleinamerica.org/missing/Kaleah-Bailey-Cannady



Hope in every heartbeat. 💓

12/09/2025

47 years. That is how long it has been since Theresa Corley was found on December 8, 1978, tossed off the side of Route 495 in Bellingham. For 47 years, her family has been searching for answers.

For 47 years, people who know something, or heard something, have chosen not to speak. For 47 years, what happened to Theresa hasn’t important enough for those who know to bring the truth forward.

If you have any information about the night Theresa was in Franklin or when she was last seen in Bellingham, please come forward.

☎️ Call 855-MA-SOLVE, the Massachusetts State Police Unresolved Case Unit tip line for unsolved murdered and missing persons cases across the Commonwealth.

12/08/2025

There is zero chance that it was not “atypical” that Ana went “several days” without communicating with Brian Walshe, who was caring for their three sons while she worked in Washington, DC.
No way.

12/05/2025

Week one wrapped in the Brian Walshe murder trial.

12/05/2025

Day five in the murder trial of Brian Walshe:

Friday marks Day 5 of testimony in Brian Walshe’s high-profile murder trial after Ana Walshe's boyfriend was called to the stand.More coverage at Boston25New...

12/05/2025

Every year, for many years, we have come together as a community to support foster families in the Boston area. This year, we will gather at The Burren in Davis Square in Somerville to celebrate the season, collect unwrapped gifts, and enjoy performances by Gene Dante and the Future Starlets and Lovina Falls. Please help us spread some needed goodwill and holiday cheer.
📍The Burren, 247 Elm St, Somerville
​🗓️ Friday, December 19, 7-9pm
❄️Collecting unwrapped gifts for children of all ages, infants to teenagers, to included toys, books, electronics, art supplies, games, hats, mittens, personal care items, hoodies, sporting goods. Wonderfund MA wish list link posted below. We also have a local drop off location.

12/03/2025

On December 3, 1999, a fire broke out at an abandoned warehouse at 266 Franklin Street in Worcester, Massachusetts - a massive, six story windowless concrete box of a structure. Its maze-like design proved to be deadly. No one event impacted the city of Worcester more in the last 26 years than the Worcester Cold Storage Warehouse Fire that claimed the lives of six firefighters.
The Worcester Six: Paul Brotherton, Jeremiah Lucey, Thomas Spencer, Timothy Jackson, James Lyons, and Joseph McGuirk.

My two-part story: Episode 22+23 | The Worcester 6: The Cold Storage Warehouse Fire, Worcester, Massachusetts

https://www.crimeofthetruestkind.com/worcester-six

12/02/2025

On Tuesday, December 1, 1987, Andrew Gustafson had been trying to reach his wife Priscilla all afternoon. Priscilla "Cilla" was 33, and a preschool teacher at Townsend Cooperative Playschool. His law practice was nearby. That day he had just closed a big real estate deal as an associate had given him a stake in ownership of a hotel in the town of Gardner in exchange for legal services. Andrew was excited and wanted to celebrate.

He tried to get her on the phone, hoping they could have the babysitter come over and look after their daughter, Abigail, or Abby, who was turning 8 in a week, and William - Billy - who had just turned 5. But Andrew Gustafson's calls were going unanswered. He drove the mile or so home, getting there around 5:20pm, and saw Priscilla's car in the driveway. The sun had already set, and he found the house was dark. Priscilla was early in her pregnancy and the family was excited to welcome the new baby. Andrew went inside, finding the house eerily quiet. Where were the kids?

Listen to the episode: https://www.crimeofthetruestkind.com/gustafson-family-murders

No one could be prepared for what came next. He walked up the stairs to their bedroom. There he found Priscilla in their bed, completely still, her head covered with a pillow. The part of her he could see was ashen and lifeless. Fear washed over him. Terrified to look for the children for fear of what he might find, he sat in the kitchen and waited for the police to arrive.

Billy was in the upstairs bathroom, he'd been drowned in the tub. Abby was in the first floor bathroom and met the same fate.
She was one week away from her 8th birthday, and had a sleepover planned that weekend.

Andrew Gustafson had lost his entire family in the span of a few hours on a Tuesday afternoon. Everything became a struggle from that day on.

He would soon find out that the monster responsible for taking his entire family from him lived a mile away and was known to Townsend Police.

12/01/2025

🔊What Happened To Amy Sher? 📍Billerica, Massachusetts | In part two of Amy Sher's story, I share how the abuse she suffered went on for years as everyone around her tried desperately to reach her.

Inspired by the award-winning film, Three Billboards Outside Ebbing, Missouri--about a mother's grief and a town's apathy--Amy's family made a public plea for answers, unveiling billboards in the area she was last seen that asked one question: “What Happened To Amy?”

Learn the real life story that inspired "Three Billboards," and a father's mission to hold the man he believes killed his daughter to account.

This episode deals with violence against women and domestic abuse. Please listen with care.
https://www.crimeofthetruestkind.com/amy-sher-2

Amy's case highlights the devastating impact of isolation, coercive control, gaslighting, inaction on the part of authorities, and the resilience of families who continue to fight for answers, even when justice feels out of reach. With hope, they ask for anyone who may remember something from those days in the fall of 2002 when Amy was last seen, and what neighbors saw and heard.

We explore how Amy’s disappearance became both a true crime mystery and a community call to action, connecting her story to cultural touchstones like award-winning films, Three Billboards Outside Ebbing, Missouri and the 1944 classic, Gaslight.

Apple Podcasts - https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/what-happened-to-amy-sher-billerica-mass-part-two/id1526251051?i=1000739097116

Spotify - https://open.spotify.com/show/5zsB8unfXnVtnJqTcnDtXE

Acast - https://shows.acast.com/crime-of-the-truest-kind/episodes/whathappenedtoamysher

11/30/2025

We remember Rita Hester, born Nov 30, 1963. She was found near death on Nov 28, 1998 in her Park Vale Ave apartment in Allston, stabbed multiple times. She died before reaching the hospital. Rita's case remains unsolved. Hear episode 53 about Rita's story. I am due for an update to her case.

Listen: https://www.crimeofthetruestkind.com/rita-hester

11/30/2025

UPDATE! Malani has been located and is safe. Thank you for sharing.

🚨 Missing in Dorchester! Malani Pina, age 14, was last seen around 9:00 AM on November 29, 2025, leaving the area of 104 Bowdoin Avenue. A short time later, she was reportedly observed near the Dudley Square Bus Station, where she may have boarded MBTA Bus Route 66.

She is described as a Black female, approximately 5-foot-2 and 150 pounds, with long red hair. At the time she went missing, she was wearing all black clothing and carrying a black backpack. Malani is also known to visit the Harambee Park and Ripley Road Playground areas, widening the scope of the search.

The Boston Police Department is reviewing the circumstances of her disappearance and is asking anyone who has seen Malani Pina or knows her whereabouts to contact 911 or BPD Detectives at (617) 343-4335.j