08/26/2025
The Boyne City Commission today (Tuesday) decided to hire Acting City Manager John Matthews as their permanent manager after learning that their previous choice, Elle Cole of Saline, has declined the position. Matthews’ hiring is subject to negotiating his salary and other contract details.
Mayor Tim Nemecek sent a memo to the commission Tuesday morning, stating that “After careful consideration, Ms. Cole has made the very difficult decision to decline the offer. In her message to me, Ms. Cole explained that unforeseen family logistics arose after she accepted the position, making it impossible for her to fully commit to Boyne City in the way she feels the community deserves.”
“She emphasized that her decision is not a reflection of Boyne City, its leadership, or the contract offered, but rather the result of personal family circumstances outside her control. Ms. Cole expressed deep admiration for our community, appreciation for the confidence the Commission placed in her, and assurance that she continues to hold Boyne City in the highest regard,” Nemecek said.
Nemececk noted that James Freed of the city’s executive search consultant, Pivot Municipal Services, “has provided a professional recommendation that the Commission consider appointing the second-place candidate, John Matthews. Mr. Matthews possesses the qualifications required for the role and has the support of a super majority of the Commission. Mr. Freed has also expressed doubt that reopening the search would result in a stronger candidate than Mr. Matthews.”
A number of citizens and city officials spoke in support of Matthews’ hiring during the meeting. Those speaking included Police Chief Kevin Spate, Director of Public Works and Utilities Doug Varney, Fire Chief Dennis Amesbury, Harbormaster Ralph Galbraith, Evangeline Township Board member Michelle Cortright, and Waterfront Field of Dreams representative Al Aown.
Thursday’s Boyne Citizen will have more details about this and other City Commission action.
The City of Boyne City Boyne City Main Street Boyne Area Chamber Tim Nemecek- Boyne City Commissioner