Erie County Blotter.

10/15/2025

The Buffalo Police Department is asking for your help to find missing 15-year-old Wah Wah Eh and 11-year-old Ehner Dah. Police say the two were last seen on Plymouth Avenue near West Ferry Street.

🔗 to story in comments.

10/15/2025

☄️ A Once-in-a-Lifetime Cosmic Visitor

On October 21, 2025, Comet C/2025 A1 will make an extraordinary approach coming within just 0.15 million kilometers of Earth, even closer than the Moon ! This icy traveler, about 1.2 km across, hasn’t visited our skies in 15,000 years, making its return a truly historic celestial encounter.

As it nears the Sun and Earth the comet’s surface will heat up, releasing glowing gas and dust that form a brilliant tail visible to the naked eye for several weeks. Astronomers expect it to outshine most stars creating a spectacular display across night skies worldwide.

Such close passages are extremely rare, and for many, this will be a once-in-human-history sight a glowing messenger from the outer Solar System reminding us of the wonders that drift through the cosmic dark.

10/15/2025

🚨 Animal Cruelty Arrest – Jamestown 🚨

On Tuesday, October 14th, 2025, at approximately 3:31 PM, officers from the Jamestown Police Department Second Platoon responded to a residence on the city’s north side following a report of animal cruelty.

Upon arrival, officers discovered two malnourished dogs in visibly poor health. After an investigation, officers arrested the dogs’ owners, identified as Robert J. Santiago and Melissa E. Santiago. Both dogs were immediately seized for care and evaluation.

Robert and Melissa Santiago were transported to the city jail, where they were booked and released with appearance tickets. Both are facing two counts each of Overdriving, Torturing, and Injuring Animals; Failure to Provide Sustenance under New York State law.

The dogs are now safe and receiving proper care. The case remains under investigation.

10/15/2025

🐾 LANCASTER - FOUND KITTEN 🐾
A young kitten was found and rescued near Walden Ave and Pavement Rd in Lancaster thats been reported to been showing up for a few weeks now.

If you believe this kitten is yours, please contact us directly at [email protected] with proof of ownership.

If no owner comes forward after its quarantine period, the kitten will be available for adoption once fully vetted.

As always, it is now safe and warm. Cat litter, the non clumping style, is always appreciated for these moments.

Better photos in morning after it settles.

10/14/2025

Search Warrant Leads to Multiple Drug Arrests in Jamestown

JAMESTOWN, NY — On Wednesday, October 9, 2025, at approximately 12:04 PM, members of the Jamestown Metro Drug Task Force and Chautauqua County Sheriff’s Office Narcotics Investigators executed a search warrant at an upper apartment located at 17 W. 7th Street in the City of Jamestown.

Upon entry, officers located Wendy K. Merrill, Tiffany A. Mahoney, and five additional individuals inside the residence. David C. Burkhart III was found on the front porch attempting to gain entry as officers approached.

During the search, investigators discovered approximately 10.4 grams of methamphetamine, 7.3 grams of fentanyl, a small quantity of crack co***ne, along with digital scales, packaging materials, hypodermic needles, and a small amount of cash.

As a result of the investigation:

Wendy K. Merrill and Tiffany A. Mahoney were each charged with:

Two counts of Criminal Possession of a Controlled Substance in the 3rd Degree

Criminal Possession of a Controlled Substance in the 4th Degree

Criminal Possession of a Controlled Substance in the 7th Degree

Two counts of Criminally Using Drug Paraphernalia in the 2nd Degree

David C. Burkhart III was charged with Criminal Possession of a Controlled Substance in the 7th Degree and was also found to have an outstanding warrant with Jamestown City Court.

The five remaining subjects were released from the scene without charges. Merrill, Mahoney, and Burkhart were transported to the Jamestown City Jail pending arraignment.

Due to the deplorable conditions of the apartment, the Jamestown Department of Development was called to the scene and subsequently condemned the residence.

The Jamestown Police Department was assisted by the Chautauqua County Sheriff’s Office and the Department of Development during the operation.

Authorities continue to urge anyone with information about drug or criminal activity to contact the Jamestown Police Department Tip Line at 716-483-TIPS (8477) or the Chautauqua County Sheriff's Office Tip Line at 800-344-8702 or 716-664-2420.

10/14/2025

We are open today until 4pm today. Come Out to the Wyoming County SPCA and See Our Beautiful Furr'-Missiles that would LOVE an Open Floor at Your Home to Run, Play, Love and Simply Enjoy Life. We Welcome Everyone!

10/13/2025

🙏🏼🕊😞

Today we honor the memory of Lt. Craig Lehner, Buffalo Police Department, who made the ultimate sacrifice while serving the City of Buffalo.

Lt. Lehner was a dedicated officer, K9 handler, and member of the Underwater Recovery Team whose courage and professionalism inspired everyone who had the privilege to know him. His legacy continues to live on through the officers he trained, the lives he touched, and the community he served with pride.

Rest easy, Lt. Lehner. We will never forget your service, your sacrifice, or your example. 🖤💙🖤

10/13/2025

Here are your Cheektowaga Police Department Patrol Logs arranged from a list of submitted calls.

Dates: October 6 – October 12, 2025.

The Cheektowaga Police Department handled numerous calls for service during the week. Below is a summary of notable incidents and police activity.

Monday, October 6, 2025
00:21 – Attempted Vehicle Larceny – Rutland Ave
A male was observed entering multiple vehicles before being scared off. Nothing was reported stolen.

15:51 – Animal Bite – St. Felix Ave
A juvenile sustained a hand injury after being bitten by loose dogs. The Dog Warden was notified.

23:00 – Fraud – Idlebrook Dr
A landlord reported a tenant used counterfeit $50 bills to pay rent. A police report and warrant application were completed.

Tuesday, October 7, 2025
00:08 – Disturbance – Atwood Pl
Officers responded to a physical altercation between two individuals. One person sustained minor head and facial injuries and was treated by AMR.

Wednesday, October 8, 2025
02:36 – Open Building – French Rd
Officers located an unsecured door and found the front door wedged open. The premises were checked and secured.

Thursday, October 9, 2025
00:11 – Suspicious Occurrence – Pendennis Pl
A witness reported seeing a male in a ski mask drop a pistol while exiting a black Dodge Charger. The male picked up the firearm and left the area in an Uber. Officers checked the area with negative results.

15:36 – Identity Theft – Police Headquarters
A victim reported unauthorized access to their bank account, resulting in a $900 loss. A police report was filed.

Friday, October 10, 2025
00:52 – Narcotics Arrest – Claudette Ct
An intoxicated male was taken into custody on drug-related charges. One arrest made.

16:52 – S*x Offense Report – Melcourt Dr
Parents reported concerns involving their son. A police report was filed, and the Child Advocacy Center was notified.

Saturday, October 11, 2025
00:24 – Large Disturbance – Genesee St
Officers responded to a fight involving 10–15 people in the street stemming from an Airbnb party. The crowd dispersed upon police arrival.

17:48 – DWI Arrest – Harlem Rd
A driver was stopped and arrested for Driving While Intoxicated. The vehicle was towed from the scene.

Sunday, October 12, 2025
01:12 – Attempted Break-In – Dartwood Dr
A homeowner, monitoring their security camera remotely, observed two males attempting to enter their residence. The suspects fled on foot and were not located.

22:57 – Suspicious Person – Windwood Ct
Officers located a confused or intoxicated person sitting in a resident’s vehicle. The individual was transported to ECMC for evaluation.

The Cheektowaga Police Department reminds residents to keep doors locked, remove valuables from vehicles, and report any suspicious activity.

10/13/2025