05/31/2026
I’ve watched the first two episodes of *Spider-Noir* and, so far, I’m enjoying it.
The aesthetic and time period are fantastic. The series really leans into its pulp detective roots, and at times it feels like a Spider-Man story filtered through *Dick Tracy*. I’ve enjoyed spotting noir-inspired versions of familiar Marvel characters, including Robbie Robertson, Felicia Hardy, Sandman, Silvermane, and Tombstone. I’m also curious to see where some of the newer characters fit into the larger mythology. Addison, in particular, has me wondering if there’s a connection to Mark Raxton, the Molten Man. And judging by the trailers, it looks like Electro may be waiting in the wings as well.
That said, my biggest struggle so far is Spider-Noir himself.
Maybe I just need more time with the character, but his overall vibe feels a little off to me. The accent shifts, the theatrical delivery, and some of the puns and one-liners feel awkward compared to the rest of the cast. At times it almost feels like he’s performing in a different show while everyone else is playing the noir elements completely straight. It hasn’t ruined the series for me, but it has pulled me out of the story on a few occasions.
Overall, though, I think the show is doing something unique, and I’m interested to see where it goes from here. It has also made me want to revisit the original Spider-Noir comics by David Hine, Fabrice Sapolsky, Roger Stern, Carmine Di Giandomenico, Richard Isanove, Bob McLeod, and Paco Diaz. If anything, I’d still love to see a future adaptation that more directly captures the feel of those original stories and their younger Peter Parker.
I know a number of people responded to my earlier post saying they loved the show and especially Nicolas Cage’s performance, so I may very well be in the minority here. I'm only two episodes in, and it's entirely possible the character grows on me as the season progresses.
For those of you who have watched it, what are your thoughts so far? Am I being too hard on Cage's take on Spider-Noir, or did anyone else have a similar reaction?