
08/04/2025
SUMMARY
- Clara Smith was brutally murdered in a dorm on Marthaโs Vineyard in 1940.
- Theater instructor Ralph Rice was wrongly tried and quickly acquitted.
- Another suspect, Harold Tracy, escaped, later confessed but was never prosecuted.
- A decades-later conversation confirmed Tracy admitted to the murder.
There are many ways to solve a murder. This isnโt one of them.
A 1940 murder on Marthaโs Vineyard led to a botched trial, a guilty man walking free and a chilling confession decades later on a hotel porch.