05/08/2026
The debate around Caitlin Clark and the Indiana Fever is already heating up before the 2026 WNBA season even tips off.
During a recent segment on “WNBA on ESPN,” analyst Lawrencia Moten delivered a take that instantly sent basketball fans into a frenzy: the Indiana Fever were actually harder to defend when Caitlin Clark wasn’t on the floor.
Yes, you read that correctly.
Moten argued that Clark’s superstar presence causes the offense to revolve heavily around her, making Indiana more predictable at times. According to Moten, when Clark missed games last season due to injuries, the Fever were forced to evolve offensively and rely on a more balanced attack.
“This is my hot take,” Moten said. “Honestly, the Indiana Fever played some of their best team basketball without Caitlin Clark… The ball is constantly in her hands, which just made their offense extremely easy to guard.”
She pointed to players like Kelsey Mitchell, Lexie Hull, and Aliyah Boston stepping into larger offensive roles while Clark was sidelined, saying the team became “much more diverse” offensively.
But here’s the part fans immediately pushed back on:
Indiana still had a significantly better winning percentage with Clark in the lineup (61.5%) compared to without her (51.6%).
And social media wasted absolutely no time firing back.
“I think it helped other Indiana players develop, but not easier to guard,” one fan wrote.
Another added:
“Never heard of this person before today… She really using an injured season to say Caitlin makes the team easy to guard…”
And perhaps the most viral response:
“She doesn’t know ball at all cuz what? Caitlin Clark runs the floor when she's out there.”
Whether you agree with Moten or not, one thing is undeniable: Caitlin Clark remains the center of the basketball universe heading into the 2026 WNBA season. Now all eyes turn to Saturday’s season opener against the Dallas Wings. And if Clark comes out cooking?
This take may age VERY quickly.