06/04/2025
The MEDIC Scale: Why It Exists and Why It Matters
Too many authors focus on finishing a book, not building one that works. They spend weeks, months, even years drafting something that never connects, not because they aren’t talented, but because no one gave them a real standard to measure their work against.
That’s why I created the MEDIC Scale.
It’s not a theory, it’s a tool I designed to help authors evaluate the five areas that decide whether someone keeps reading or puts the book down. It replaces vague opinions and emotional attachments with focused, honest feedback you can actually use.
What MEDIC Stands For
Every manuscript I assess is reviewed across five key traits:
Momentum — Is the story or message moving forward with purpose? Are the first 25 pages building something?
Momentum is the difference between a reader turning the page or closing the book.
Emotional Anchor — Is there something grounding your writing — a truth, a feeling, a weight that holds the reader there?
If they don’t feel it, they won’t follow it.
Distinct Voice — Does the writing sound like you — or like everyone else? Voice is how we trust a narrator.
If I can’t hear you, I can’t connect with what you’re saying.
Immediate Attention — Is the reader pulled in right away, or are you warming up for three pages?
You don’t get ten chances to hold someone’s attention. You get ten seconds.
Clear Context — Do I know who, where, what, and why without rereading?
Confusion kills connection, Clarity invites the reader to stay.
How It Works
I apply the MEDIC Scale to five parts of your book: the cover, title, subtitle, synopsis, and first 25 pages. Each section is reviewed and scored from 1 to 10, from both a professional perspective and a reader’s perspective. The goal isn’t perfection, it’s alignment. If your book is falling short, this is where you find out why.
I’m not here to flatter, I’m here to help you fix what’s broken before it gets expensive, or public.
Why It’s Necessary
Most writers don’t get real feedback until it’s too late, after they’ve paid an editor, hit publish, or released something that didn’t land. The MEDIC Scale gives you answers before all of that.
It’s assessment with direction, clear, practical, and specific.
You deserve more than “this is good.” You deserve to know why it works, or why it doesn’t, from someone who isn’t trying to sell you a dream.
Why Me
I didn’t create this because I needed something to sell, I created it because I’ve been where most authors are, unsure, stuck, and too close to the work to see what’s missing. I’ve written books that failed, I’ve written books that won. I know what it takes to get it right.
And now, I help other writers get there too.
The MEDIC Scale isn’t about judgment.
It’s about giving you a clear path forward, so your book can do what it was meant to do: connect, move, and matter.