12/19/2025
A $1.6 million misunderstanding over the Belmont and north Fitzhugh property that houses Strangeways, a dive bar with an eclectic menu, became more than a year-long legal battle. A long legal fight, what owner Rosie Ildemaro calls an “expensively sad situation.”
Strangeways owners and siblings Eric Sanchez and Ildemaro opened the bar in August 2011. In 2023, the Heidari brothers, Pasha and Sina, known for St. Martin’s and Urbano Cafe, sought to buy the property from landlord Ana M. Martinez for $1.6 million, according to their commercial contract.
More than 60 documents were filed in the dispute. Ildemaro summarizes a lot of the situration saying, “Our landlord had to come up here to let the buyer’s bank in to do a walk through of the building, so [Sanchez] lets them in and [Ana M. Martinez], our landlord, runs into my brother, and she says in a very sweet way, because we have a really good relationship, ‘Why didn’t you want to buy the building?’ And that’s when Eric’s jaw dropped. He’s like, ‘But you decided not to sell to us. We wanted to. Rosie has all the text messages.’ And that’s when her jaw drops, too, and she’s like, ‘No, no, no, this is what I was told.”
All parties were gearing up for trial by submitting witness and exhibit lists (and objecting to each other’s lists), but then they agreed to settle the matter rather than go to trial in January of this year. They requested that the case be dismissed with prejudice, meaning the same claim cannot be refiled. The Heidaris appear to be operating business as usual and recently opened a new cocktail bar by Urbano Cafe. Strangeways’ owners retained their bar. And that property still sold for $1.6 million.
https://lakewood.advocatemag.com/strangeways-survived-lawsuit/
📷️:
A $1.6 million misunderstanding. That’s what an over-year long fight for ownership of the property near Belmont and north Fitzhugh Avenues, where Strangeways is, boiled down to. Strangeways owners and siblings Eric Sanchez and Rosie Ildemaro opened the bar in August 2011. Strangeways, named after ...