11/05/2025
Fayette voters reject measure to change elected City Marshal to appointed Police Chief
Voters in Fayette rejected the city’s proposal to change the elected position of City Marshal to that of Chief of Police, which is appointed by the Mayor and approved by the council.
The measure was rejected 169-134.
Fayette’s Board of Aldermen put the measure on the ballot Tuesday, hoping an appointed Chief would broaden the available candidates for the job. State statute requires an elected Marshal to live within the city limits, while an appointed Chief does not have such a geographic restriction.
Three hundred and four ballots were cast as 23.62% percent of the town’s 1,287 registered voters turned out to make their voices heard in what had become a hot-button issue in recent weeks. Opponents rallied against taking away the citizens’ rights to vote for the Marshal and worry that the change is the first step toward disbanding the Fayette Police Department altogether in favor of contracting with the Sheriff’s Department for citywide law enforcement coverage.
Such a move is not unheard of in small counties. The City of New Franklin dissolved its city police department in April 2021 to contract with the sheriff’s department. And with the sheriff’s office located just one block off the downtown square in Fayette, such a transition here is not considered impractical.
Supporters of the change suggest the city could save around $200,000 a year by contracting with the county and the sheriff’s department for city law enforcement. How those savings would be used has not been addressed, although continued demands for street improvements remain high among residents here.
While contracting with the sheriff’s department has been mentioned, it has not been cited by the city as the main reason for switching to an appointed Chief. Although some speculate that this is the principal driver behind the city’s push.
Current City Marshal Timothy “Bo” Wells stated he planned to run for a full term if the voters rejected the change. He was appointed Marshal by the council in August when David Ford retired from the position. The term expires at the time of the next municipal elections in April. He can now run for a full four-year term as City Marshal. The candidate filing period opens at 8 a.m. on December 9 and closes at 5 p.m. on December 30. Elections will be held on April 7, 2026.