07/24/2025
If you’re watching season 2 of Shiny Happy People on Prime and have complicated emotions about Teen Mania, evangelical subculture, and what it meant to be “on fire for God” in the ‘90s and 2000s—this is for you.
WHEN WE WERE ON FIRE by Addie Zierman is an honest, deeply relatable memoir about growing up evangelical—and what happens when the flame goes out.
In the strange, us-versus-them world of youth rallies, WWJD bracelets, and purity pledges, Addie was a poster child for the faith. But when the fire burned out, she found herself lost in questions, depression, and disillusionment—and searching for a new way forward.
⭐️“When We Were on Fire is a true work of art. It’s big, wide, deep, and true.” —Glennon Doyle
⭐️“A book to savor to the very last page.” —Publisher’s Weekly (starred review)
This is a story for those feeling the ache of old faith wounds and are still healing.
WHEN WE WERE ON FIRE is the book to read after the documentary ends.
Amazon When We Were on Fire: A Memoir of Consuming Faith, Tangled Love, and Starting OverAddie ZiermanIn the strange, us-versus-them world of ’90s Christian subculture, faith was measured in Jesus fish, WWJD bracelets, and purity pledges. And Addie Zierman was an evangelical poster child—so “o...