12/30/2024
A notebook, stitched-seam with black paper binding. Dark blue with a floral pattern on the cover. Just slightly larger than my hands, with a nice weight to it.
On the cover it has a little area for writing the title or name or topic of the notebook.
My handwriting, slightly stilted, reads: "Sarah is a people, too."
The notebook is empty.
I didn't know what to write inside of it.
There's a fallacy called "Heaven's Reward" which is a cognitive distortion that says if you sacrifice enough, work hard enough or struggle enough, there will be a reward at the end. I've never quite believed this.
The truth is, a person can try very very hard and do their very very best and people can look at them with contempt, view them as lazy, and view everything about them as floofish nonsense.
A perfectly ordinary human being can show up needing comfort and reassurance that all of the complicated, weirdness that we experience as people.. All the emotions, the attractions, the thoughts, feelings, overwhelm, the questions we have, the horrible mistakes we have made in the past.. All of it.. Is valid. And it all is.
And then that person can absolutely dismantle another person who is also perfectly ordinary and a squishy human being with their own insecurities and faults and things they struggle with and their preferences and the things they need in order to feel safe and human.
There is a list of people that I regret providing support to. Not because they were undeserving of support. Not because anything was an awful horrible flaw with them. But because at the end of the day there was nothing reciprocal. I was not also a people. I was a means to an end. A validation of everything in them while being a contemptible nonsense within myself.
It feels weird and recursive, like it's triggered a mental script traversing backwards and chipping away at a problem. If this thing about me is true, then I'm afraid I've misled you and all of these things that I have reassured you about are false. Not because I believe you to be invalid, but because you believe me to be invalid and if that is true then it applies to you within your world view.
I can't provide you with validation if I am invalid. I cannot reassure you that this particular thing about you is perfectly normal if it's not also normal in me. I can't accept you if I'm unacceptable to you.
I'm sorry.
It's so odd. To have questioned myself for so long, because of those people that questioned me while seeking out my reassurance. To have learned to reassure, to accept, to understand that everyone has faults and flaws and breaking points and that everyone is human... Because people I loved needed that from me.
But then that couldn't apply to me for some reason.
But it does. Within how I view people and humanity.
I don't need to write anything in that notebook because me being a people too... Is a coherent part of my world view. The only reason I needed to think about that and reassure myself is because some of the people that I was reassuring... were doing the opposite with me.
It's weird trying to explain to another human being that it's not that I view video games or alcohol or anything with contempt.
It's that if I view those things the way I view them, I can't accept that silly little things about myself and about other people are worthy of contempt.
I cannot agree with you logically that video games are a perfectly adult wonderful beautiful hobby when you have shared with me the opinion that women that like bouquets of flowers are somehow dumb. I don't even particularly like cut flowers myself. I like to cut flowers and give them to people that like them. Because other peoples likes are beautiful wonderful things. And if you think back on my interactions with you, you'll see all the ways in which I viewed you in this way, too. In the gifts I gave. You will see no contempt there. You will see amusement and love and all of those things that people deserve.
I can't agree with you that anything about you is valid when you think that other peoples preferences are objectively inferior and that you use logic and reason to approach all of your problems. It would be illogical and unreasonable for me to do so. Cut flowers are dumb because they just die. Video games are dumb because they were never alive to begin with. See? Problem sorted. Romance novels are just dumb. But action flicks are amazing entertainment as terrible actors pretend to be karate experts? You kidding me, bro? Logic is a broad application, not a "I like this, therefore it is true". People like what they like. You like what you like. And it's awesome. Your likes are valid. Unless you crap all over someone else's likes, then your likes are equally nonsensical crap. And yes, this is where you proclaim me abusive because I'm saying your likes aren't valid. Which... Is not an actual thing.
It's not that I judge you or your hobbies.
It's that I am not a reassurance provision machine and I no longer want to reassure or validate people that look at ordinary squishy humanity and human preferences with contempt. If other people deserve your road rage, your contempt, your proclamations of ridiculousness, your insistence that they are illogical and emotional and you hold the one true valid state of ultimate authority and intellect where you can look down on them for everything they are...
I'm allowed to view you with contempt. I'm not obligated to provide you with something that I view as a beautiful wonderful basic life-giving part of society while you hold these contemptuous negative views of other peoples perfectly squishy human ordinary normalness.
I can't both listen to and agree with you that other drivers are insufferable idiots while also reassuring you that you are not an insufferable idiot and that everyone makes mistakes.
And I cannot... Will not.. Never again.. Ever look at myself and try to see all the things you hold contempt for and try to fix them for you.
I don't need to write in that notebook. I'm a human. I'm a people. And I am allowed to give myself the same grace that people and humans deserve.
I don't have to give you that grace. I am allowed to take every item of judgment that you have ever shared with me and plop it down upon your head.
I cannot simultaneously accept that I am lazy and worthless while accepting that you playing video games next to a bowl full of rotting food and mouse droppings and a box full of fleas is valid. I can accept that the task is overwhelming and that you need help. I can give you all the grace in the world and accept you the way I accept other people. But not while you're projecting everything you're failing at onto me and onto other people. I can't choke down the words that I have "never grown up" and "may need therapy" while you... are who you are. What is that, even?
I don't want to. It's not who I am as a person. You know what you say about other people. Turn it inwards. Swallow your own contempt. It's harsh and you will probably choke on it. No one likes the flavor. It's like a lump of burning hot broken glass-coal and it tastes like p**p.
And yeah. No one deserves it. Even you.
Within my world-view you are a perfectly ordinary and beautiful person and I have a lot of love and appreciation and respect for you. Within my world-view you are just doing what you have learned and seen and heard and you're just doing your best and it's hard to adopt new patterns as an adult.
But you were incredibly incredibly cruel to someone who had only ever tried to be kind to you.
And that is not okay.
(This is not about a single person, unfortunately. It's about a life-long experience of the paradox of tolerance and about realizing why my notebook is empty. It's not because I'm not a people. It's because I don't need to prove that to myself because I have spent my life making sure that I understand that about everyone around me.)
Unless you are a child, I will not give you what you insist others do not deserve.
You have made a very logical and unemotional decision about who deserves contempt. It is a very logical and unemotional fact that a lot of your actions are well under that threshold. I'm not saying that I have contempt for you.
I'm asking you why you don't recognize that you should have contempt for yourself within the framework that you have established and the approach you take to judging things and people around you.
I'm not saying you "should" have contempt for yourself. I don't think it's a useful thing for people to feel for themselves or others. I believe that contempt is cruel and awful. What I'm saying that if you're internally consistent with your plotline and beliefs, you and others should feel contempt for who and what you are. Why are you coming to me for reassurance when you view me as worthy of your contempt? My opinion is already emotional, invalid, and I'm just providing you with what you need to be an awful person, no?
Send a message to learn more