Murder Sheet

04/21/2026

04/18/2026

Our book Shadow of the Bridge: The Delphi Murders and the Dark Side of the American Heartland (August 26, 2025 | Pegasus) won the top award in the nonfiction book category of the 2025 Best in Indiana Journalism Awards.

Thank you to the Indiana Professional Chapter of the Society for Professional Journalists for this honor!

04/11/2026

Thanks to the listener who gifted Nick some brand new bow ties! He's now a very stylish gent!

04/08/2026

Murder Sheet · Episode

04/06/2026

We are proudly endorsing Stacey Diener for White County prosecutor. She did an incredible job in the Delphi trial. She is a seasoned, tough, and smart prosecutor and will serve the people of White County well.

03/12/2026

So excited for this event at the Marion Public Library tonight! Starts in a few minutes. 💜🩵

03/05/2026

Come see us next week at the Marion Public Library in Marion, Ohio! We can't wait to meet some of you and sign books!

02/04/2026

Have you seen Lillyn Marie Key?

Lillyn is 16. She has been missing from Avon, Indiana since January 12, 2026. She may still be in Avon. She also may have gone to Indianapolis or Vevay in Indiana, or Chicago, Illinois.

Please share her information and keep an eye out. Especially if you're in those areas. Call 911 if you see her.

Missing From: Avon, IN. Missing Date: January 12, 2026.

01/16/2026

This is super scary. We need to find Hailey. Check out the original post for more information on her case.

🚨 BOLO: MISSING & ENDANGERED - HAILEY BUZBEE 🚨

What We Know & FAQ’s ⬇️⬇️

⏰LAST SEEN ON: Hailey Paige Buzbee was last seen on January 5th, 2026 at approximately 10pm in Indiana.
​
—She was last seen by her parents in her bedroom, located in the Enclave at Vermillion neighborhood.
(E 101st St & W Ohio St, Fishers, Indiana)

👚 👜 CLOTHING & ITEMS: Hailey was wearing a black puffer jacket and took a bag with her. We know this because these items are no longer at the home. However, she could be wearing anything now.

💇‍♀️🎀HAIR: Hailey’s hair was braided when she was last seen. However, it could now be natural (curly) or straightened.

⚠️⛔️DANGER: It is unlike Hailey to not only “run away”, but to not contact any of her family members or friends in the last 11 days.

Hailey was very close with her family. She was going to a great school, she had a job, she was working on getting her license, she was figuring life out. There was no reason for her to run away.

Her family believes that she is likely in a dangerous situation and did not act alone.

——— FAQ’s ———

🗺️👣 SEARCH PARTY: Are there any in-person searches that we can help with?

—It is highly unlikely that Hailey left on foot. At this point in time, we believe that she could be anywhere. Please continue to keep an eye out for her and share her flyers.

🏞️🌳FLAT FORK PARK: Have you searched the park where she was seen?

——✋🛑 Hailey was NOT seen at a park. It was mentioned that she lives near the Flat Fork Park, as a place mark to understand the area she was last seen at.

📄 🖨️ FLYERS: How can I get a PDF file of the flyers? I would like to print them.

—PDF’s of the flyers are available at the QR code & 🔗 below!

🙋‍♀️🙋‍♂️❓: HOW CAN I HELP?

— Please help by sharing Hailey’s photos and flyers. Our goal is simple: to make Hailey’s face so familiar that if she walks into a gas station, store, or restaurant, someone recognizes her, makes the call, and helps bring her home.

ℹ️👀 TIPS: All tips should be directed to law enforcement. You can call Hamilton County Dispatch 24 hours a day, 7 days a week at 317-773-1282. ☎️ If you SEE Hailey, please take a photo / video , do not approach her and call 9-1-1.

Additionally, there is an online (ANONYMOUS) tip form that can be filled out at the webpage ⬇️. Each tip is automatically sent to law enforcement.

01/16/2026

We spoke to the amazing Ryan Bailey of So Bad It's Good about our book Shadow of the Bridge: The Delphi Murders and the Dark Side of the American Heartland. We were blown away — he is a wonderful interviewer. His questions were so thoughtful. Check out the conversation here (also, while he does some great true crime coverage, if you love pop culture and reality TV, he's a must-watch as well):

**SPONSOR INFORMATION**Refresh your winter wardrobe with Quince. Go to https://Quince.com/sobad for free shipping on your order and 365-day returns.FOLLOW AI...

12/23/2025

12/12/2025

Our book is Amazon Kindle's Deal of the Day!

Shadow of the Bridge: The Delphi Murders and the Dark Side of the American Heartland is now only $1.99 on Kindle. That deal is around just for today, December 12, 2025.

Our book — from Pegasus Books — tells the story of two young girls who helped solve their own murders.

It's the chilling, definitive account of the brutal 2017 double homicide of Libby German and Abby Williams in Delphi, Indiana. Our readers have called it empathetic, propulsive, and disturbing. Publishers Weekly called Shadow of the Bridge a book that will "get under readers' skin."

If you've already read the book and liked it, please share this news on social media and let your bookish friends know. Every bit helps! Especially with the holidays coming up.

You can find the deal on Amazon Kindle's ‘Great on Kindle Goldbox’ page.