Buried Bylines Podcast

Home
United States
Indianapolis, IN
Buried Bylines Podcast

Official account for the Buried Bylines Podcast! Be warned, humor is how we deal with bad/upsetting things. 🤷🏻‍♀️ New episodes drop every other Wednesday.

05/28/2026

Hiiiieeee! Megan here! Apologies for the late episode drop. I’m just a single mom (no, I’m not. I have a husband who is very present) who works two jobs (I only have one job but I’m tired) who loves her kids and never stops… (I do, and never.)

In all seriousness though, 99 episodes later and somehow the internet still lets us talk into microphones every week. ❤️

Before Episode 100 drops, we’re doing a Q&A episode answering your questions, reflecting on the journey so far, discussing what the NEXT 100 episodes could look like… and finally revealing the infamous cold case we’ll be covering for our 100th episode. 👀
We’re also doing a merch giveaway to celebrate! To enter:
⭐ Rate the podcast
⭐ Leave a written review
⭐ Send us a screenshot once you do!

Seriously — every review helps more people find our show, and we’re so grateful for all of you who have listened, supported, shared episodes, and spiraled with us along the way.

Episode 99 is available now. Episode 100 is coming VERY soon.

05/26/2026

We’re doing a Q&A episode this week, as we prep for our big 100th episode. Comment all your burning questions below! They can be personal, case related, news related, etc.

05/13/2026

Scientists connected to nuclear, aerospace, and government research are disappearing, turning up dead, or becoming the center of chilling conspiracy theories. Now the FBI and Congress are investigating.
In this episode, we break down the mysterious deaths and disappearances that have sparked fears of espionage, coverups, and something far more sinister. Are these tragic coincidences… or is there a connection hiding beneath the surface?
🎙️ Listen now wherever you get your podcasts.
TrueCrimePodcast MissingPersons FBI NASA

05/02/2026

Apologies in advance for the late episode drop. Sickness hit both of our households at the same time and we produce and edit ourselves. 🫠

Here is the case: In 2011, Essie McVey was shot inside her Greencastle, Indiana condo—and more than a decade later, her case is still unsolved.

No forced entry.
No signs of a struggle.
Nothing stolen.

Investigators believe it may have been a burglary gone wrong… but with no witnesses, no weapon, and almost no evidence, the truth has remained just out of reach.

Police say they’re close—that they have most of the puzzle… But someone out there is still holding the missing piece.

🎧 This week’s episode dives into the case that nobody seems to be talking about—and why that might be.

📍 Do you remember this case? Or have you heard anything over the years?

📞 Anyone with information is urged to contact Greencastle Police Department at (765) 653-3155.

TrueCrimePodcast

04/15/2026

In 1964, 18-year-old Eleanor Kaatz was attacked on her way to school in Wisconsin. She was still alive when she was found—but died two days later from her injuries.
Her killer was caught within 24 hours.

But the violence didn’t end there.

🎙️ This week’s episode dives into a brutal, nearly forgotten case—and the man who would go on to become one of the longest-serving prisoners in the state.

04/01/2026

This January, the disappearance of Fishers teen Hailey Buzbee gripped the internet…

But what started as a missing persons case quickly became something far more disturbing.

FOX59 and CBS4’s joins us to break down the details—and the bigger, more alarming pattern behind cases like this.

🎙️New episode out now.🎀

03/23/2026

Note: We will never condone domestic violence and our hearts go out to Taylor’s children who have been subjected to this in more ways than one. The situation seems to be a bit more nuanced than people are making it out to be online.

we hope you’re getting the help and support you need 🫶🏼

03/19/2026

Speculation Station is parked in Morgantown, West Virginia, this week—where we examine the murders of two college freshmen whose case still lingers in uncertainty... despite *technically being closed.
When best friends Mared Malarik and Karen Ferrell disappeared after a night out at the movies, it was initially written off as a possible runaway situation or hitchhiking gone wrong. Months later, the community was confronted with a far darker and more disturbing reality when their bodies were discovered in the woods.
Strap in and let us know if YOU think they got it right in the 1970 WVU Coed Murders.

03/05/2026

A pregnant woman disappears just weeks before her due date…

Three weeks later, her body is found in a Michigan forest — and investigators uncover a horrifying plot allegedly involving members of her own family.
This week we’re covering the heartbreaking case of Rebecca Park, a 22-year-old mother-to-be whose disappearance turned into one of the most disturbing true-crime cases in recent years.
🎙️ New episode available now.

02/25/2026

Due to one half of the podcast moving almost 500 miles away, (💔) we will drop episode 93 NEXT Wednesday.

On a related note, if you have any Wisconsin cases, drop the in the comments!

Address

Indianapolis, IN

Website

https://www.buriedbylinespod.com/

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Buried Bylines Podcast posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Buried Bylines Podcast:

Shortcuts

Featured

Indianapolis Business Journal
1 Monument Circle

Want your business to be the top-listed Media Company in Indianapolis?