08/06/2026
In September 2024, Cherise Doyley, a mother and doula, was in active labor at UF Health Jacksonville when hospital officials sought a court order to authorize a Cesarean section after she declined the procedure.
During labor, she participated in a virtual court hearing from her hospital bed without legal representation. The judge initially ruled that she could continue attempting a vaginal birth unless a medical emergency arose.
Later, after doctors reported concerns about the baby’s condition, Doyley underwent an emergency C-section.
The case has sparked ongoing conversations about informed consent, patient autonomy, emergency medical decision-making, and racial disparities in maternal healthcare.
Regardless of where you stand on the issue, the story reminds us that every expectant mother should be informed about her healthcare options before labor begins.
Here are a few important takeaways:
Have open conversations with your healthcare provider throughout your pregnancy.
Create a birth plan, while understanding that emergencies can require changes.
Bring a trusted advocate or support person to the hospital whenever possible.
Don’t hesitate to ask questions about recommended treatments, their risks, benefits, and alternatives.
If you have a high-risk pregnancy, discuss potential emergency scenarios with your provider ahead of time so you’re prepared.
This story continues to raise important legal and ethical questions that healthcare professionals, attorneys, policymakers, and patient advocates are still debating today.
We’ll continue following developments and bringing you updates as this conversation evolves.
You’re watching Duval Connect Community Talk—keeping you informed about the stories impacting our community.
