09/08/2026
Earlier this year, Lake Charles resident Terrell Deshotel submitted a public records request to the city of Lake Charles, seeking an aggregate count of distracted driving citations issued over the last five years for a research project.
The city’s response caught him by surprise. Lake Charles City Attorney Russell Stutes refused to release records unless Deshotel provided government-issued photo identification, something Deshotel suspected to be a violation of state public records law. So, in May, he filed suit against the city.
Deshotel’s lawsuit is only the latest chapter in the City of Lake Charles’ years-long history of creating barriers to accessing public records, which has included legally questionable justifications for withholding records and at least one callback of records already released.
The ID requirement, Deshotel says, is an undue burden that could keep records hidden from people who have a right to see them.
“Not everybody has a photo ID,” Deshotel tells The Current. “Some indigent people don’t have ID. Some elderly people don’t have ID, but they’re still citizens. They still have the right to those records.”
Making records difficult to access is not new for the city, with complaints and legal action carrying from the past administration of Mayor Nic Hunter over to the current mayor, Marshall Simien.
Hunter’s administration faced multiple lawsuits alleging delayed production of records, overly broad interpretations of attorney-client privilege and high copying fees.
On Sept. 3, 2021, contracting and engineering firm InPwr requested records from the city related to disaster recovery work following hurricanes Laura and Delta.
Then-City Attorney David Morgan acknowledged the request, but demanded a $500 pre-payment and estimated a 21-day turnaround, according to court records.
Read more at thecurrentla.com/2026/inside-the-growing-fight-for-public-records-access-in-lake-charles/