
07/15/2024
THE PROPOSED NEW POLICE STATION: QUESTIONS, QUESTIONS AND MORE QUESTIONS
The following questions are compiled from various submissions to LF4T. Some were selected for relevancy, some as a reflection of what people understand about the project, and some for how often the question was asked. We encourage you to attend or Livestream the meeting tonight.
Click to Livestream: https://www.cityoflakeforest.com/government/agendas_and_minutes.php
FINANCIALS
The 1925 W. Field Court building was appraised in 2022 for $12.5 million. The 2023 tax assessment is $8 million. On its face, the $3.5 million purchase price seems like a deal, but is it ultimately cost effective when loss of tax revenue, retrofitting costs and future maintenance fees are factored in?
What are the yearly maintenance costs?
The building has over 98,000 sq. ft, twice as big as needed (projected need = approx.. 49,000 sq ft.), and more than a third larger when all “nice to haves” are included (approx. 59,000 sq. ft.). What other buildings were considered and rejected? Although another building’s purchase price might be higher, would a smaller building, even one with all “nice to have” options, cost less to retrofit and maintain?
How do newer police stations in peer communities compare to this plan in terms of size, needs, nice to haves, etc.? How does the City intend to pay for this project? Is a tax increase needed to support this initiative?
If the Capital Improvements levy is increased to pay for the new Police Station, will that increase exceed the Property Tax Cap as it stands today? If the cap can’t be exceeded, will other Capital Improvements need to be delayed to pay for this specific project? If so, which ones?
How would increased debt affect the City’s AAA bond rating?
How does the City’s Home Rule status figure into this decision?
Will City Council hold an advisory referendum to gauge public support?
City Manager Jason Wicha said the City may be able to lease the unused part of the building to other public safety agencies. Which agencies?
It’s going to cost us $24-28 million to retrofit roughly half the space for our police force’s needs. Are these other agencies going to pay for their own retrofit to meet their needs?
Will the current police station need to be remodeled or retrofitted to accommodate the expansion of the fire department into the vacated space? If so, what is that cost?
How are personnel and staffing needs changing over the next 10-30 years? How much will it cost the City for the added personnel?
The artificial turf athletic fields were originally estimated at $8-10 million. The final total cost was $16 million. How reliable is the $32 million total cost estimate for the new building?
Is the new building satisfactorily hardened, especially on the exterior, for a public safety building versus office space? If not, what are the costs associated with that? Are those costs incorporated into the $24-28 million dollar retrofit costs?
In the July 1 Minutes to the Special Council Meeting, Wicha said the worst-case scenario would be that the City buys the building for $3.5 million and re-sells it. The office space market is slow right now. How much money yearly would the City lose on maintenance costs plus lost tax revenue?
CITY PRIORITIES
Why was the needs assessment commissioned after the City found a building to purchase?
Why was constructing artificial turf athletic fields prioritized over a new police station, if the need for the station is so critical?
November 13, 2023 Finance Committee Minutes indicate replacement of the Recreation Center was planned for Fiscal Year (FY) 2029, and a new police station for 2031-2032. Why was the Rec Center prioritized over a new police station?
PUBLIC SAFETY AND GEOGRAPHIC LOCATION
Has there been an increase in crime in Lake Forest that justifies the need for an expanded police force and larger facility?
The proposed purchase moves the station nearly three miles west and close to the City’s western limit. Are there public safety standards that establish how to evaluate locations for police stations geographically, population-wise, response times, visibility, with respect to traffic patterns, etc.? How does the West Field Court location compare to these standards?
In an intensive emergency, where all personnel are needed, what would be the changed response times for area schools, churches, and shopping districts?
Where in the strategic plan or community survey has the idea of a police station relocation been proposed to residents?
Were other locations considered?
Has the City considered other alternatives, such as a police sub-station, that would minimize costs, increase police presence across the City, and address space considerations?
OLD/NEW BUILDING AND RETROFIT
Was refurbishing the existing building considered, at least for a shorter term of ten to twenty years? If so, what are the estimated costs associated with that project?
Are there examples of other suburban communities that have successfully converted office buildings into police stations?
MISCELLANEOUS
Who owns the building currently? What is the history of ownership?
Have we done enough due diligence to move forward with this purchase?
This building has been vacant for some years. Why has the City given itself just 90 days for due diligence? Why not provide more time to consider such a large, expensive undertaking?
The Council and residents attending the meeting have only had 15 days to consider the information presented on July 1. The minutes were posted on Saturday, July 13. The vote is on July 15. Would more time for public comment be helpful before going forward with this project?
Why wasn’t the Concord Group assessment made public? What were their results?
-LF4T