12/26/2025
She married eight men, ran businesses across four cities, was arrested multiple times—and built an empire in the only economy that would let a woman control her own money in the 1880s.
Her name was Lizzie Lape. And in Victorian America, where women couldn't vote, couldn't own property in many states, and couldn't even control their own wages if they were married, Lizzie found the one industry where women could own, operate, and profit: s*x work.
Born Elizabeth Rogers in Kentucky in 1853, Lizzie grew up during a time when a woman's options were brutally limited. You married well, or you worked in domestic service, or you starved. That was basically it.
Lizzie left Kentucky for Chicago as a teenager. We don't know exactly why—family trouble, poverty, opportunity, escape—history doesn't record those details. But we know what she did when she got there: she set up shop in Chicago's red light district.
She wasn't working the streets. She was running the operation.
At a time when most women couldn't even open a bank account without a husband's permission, Lizzie was managing money, employees, security, and clients. She was, in modern terms, a businesswoman—just in the only business where Victorian society would tolerate female ownership.
In Chicago, she met Jeremiah Lape. They married and moved to Ohio, settling in Plain City, where they had a son, Henry Arville Lape. For a moment, it might have looked like Lizzie was going to live a conventional life—marriage, motherhood, respectability.
It didn't last.
They divorced. And Lizzie went back to what she knew: running establishments.
Her second husband was the manager of a Junction House in Lima, Ohio. He was also a thief. While Lizzie wore stolen silk dresses and jewelry—enjoying the spoils of his crimes—she also paid the price when he got caught. She was arrested and incarcerated as an accomplice.
Think about that. Victorian society would jail a woman for wearing stolen dresses but wouldn't give her the legal right to refuse her husband or control her own earnings. The hypocrisy was built into the system.
After her release, Lizzie left Lima and her second husband. She headed to Marion, Ohio, where she did something remarkable: she bought property.
She purchased a saloon called the White Pigeon and a building known as "The Red House." Both establishments offered liquor, food, gambling, and s*x work—full-service entertainment venues that catered to men's desires while putting money directly into Lizzie's pocket.
This wasn't desperation. This was strategy.
Prostitution was illegal, morally condemned, and socially reviled. But it was also wildly profitable—one of the few ways a woman could accumulate significant wealth in the 19th century. Lizzie wasn't just surviving. She was building an empire.
In 1889, the law caught up with her. Lizzie was arrested for "keeping houses of ill repute" and sentenced to sixty days in a workhouse. Newspapers covered the scandal extensively, using language designed to titillate their readers—painting Lizzie as a scandalous, lascivious woman corrupting decent society.
What the newspapers didn't mention: the men who frequented her establishments—the politicians, businessmen, respectable married men—faced no consequences whatsoever.
After her release, there was more trouble. Her first husband, Jeremiah Lape, sued her for child support. Even though she'd been divorced, incarcerated, publicly shamed, and repeatedly arrested, she was still legally responsible for supporting the child from her first marriage.
She paid. And then she moved to Akron.
There, Lizzie opened The Halfway House—a prosperous establishment that was, once again, part saloon, part gambling den, part brothel. By now, she'd perfected the model. She knew how to manage staff, handle law enforcement, navigate legal gray areas, and keep the money flowing.
And somewhere in all of this, she married six more times.
The full list of surnames she collected reads like a historical telephone book: Rogers-Lape-Huffman-Larzelere-DeWitt-Veon-Shetler-France.
Eight husbands. At least six brothels. Multiple arrests. Decades of building businesses, losing them, rebuilding them. A son she supported despite imprisonment and social ostracism. A life lived entirely outside the boundaries Victorian society set for women—and yet, paradoxically, within the only economic system that allowed her independence.
Here's what makes Lizzie's story so complex:
She wasn't a victim. She wasn't a villain. She was a businesswoman operating in an economy that exploited women while simultaneously giving certain women—those willing to work in the s*x trade—unusual economic power.
Victorian prostitution was brutal. Women faced violence, disease, legal persecution, and social stigma. Many were coerced, trafficked, or driven by desperate poverty. Lizzie's story doesn't erase that reality.
But Lizzie wasn't just surviving. She was an entrepreneur. She owned property. She hired employees. She managed multiple establishments across different cities. She supported her child. She married repeatedly—possibly for love, possibly for business advantage, possibly because marriage offered legal protections or social cover she needed.
She was doing what women in legitimate businesses couldn't do: controlling her own money, making her own decisions, and building wealth without male permission.
The newspapers that covered her life painted her as scandalous, immoral, lascivious. They sold papers by condemning her. But those same newspapers never questioned why respectable society offered women like Lizzie so few legitimate options. Never asked why a woman with obvious business acumen, management skills, and entrepreneurial drive had to operate brothels because no bank would give her a loan, no business would hire her, and no legitimate industry would let her own property.
Lizzie didn't choose s*x work because she was immoral. She chose it because it was one of the only ways a woman in the 1880s could be her own boss.
She lived into the 20th century—witnessing women finally win the right to vote in 1920, though she'd been running businesses and controlling money for forty years by then. She saw the world slowly, grudgingly, start giving women the legal rights she'd had to seize through illegal means.
After her death, her story was largely forgotten—except by her descendants.
In 2010, Lizzie's great-great-granddaughter, author Kris Radish, published "Looking for Lizzie: Searching for the True Story of Elizabeth Jane Rogers Lape and Her Sporting Life Legacy." Radish spent years researching newspaper archives, court records, and family stories, trying to piece together who Lizzie really was beneath the scandalous headlines.
What she found was a woman far more complex than history remembered. Not a saint. Not a simple victim. Not a one-dimensional "madam." But a business owner, a mother, a survivor, and an entrepreneur who built multiple successful enterprises in an era when women were legally and socially powerless.
Lizzie's story doesn't fit neatly into our modern narratives about empowerment or exploitation. It's messy, morally complex, and deeply tied to the brutal realities of 19th-century gender economics.
But here's what's undeniable:
Lizzie Lape owned property when most women couldn't. She ran businesses when most women couldn't. She controlled her own money when most women couldn't. She supported her child when she was supposed to be powerless.
She did all of this by operating outside the law, outside respectability, outside the boundaries Victorian society set for women. And she paid the price—arrests, imprisonment, public condemnation, moral judgment that followed her through eight marriages and six cities.
But she kept going. She kept building. She kept opening new establishments, hiring new staff, serving new clients, making new money.
Because the alternative—obedience, dependence, powerlessness—was worse than scandal.
Victorian society offered women two choices: be controlled by men or be condemned by everyone. Lizzie chose condemnation and freedom over respectability and powerlessness.
That doesn't make her a hero. It doesn't make her a villain. It makes her someone who survived and thrived in a system designed to prevent her from doing either.
In honor of Lizzie Rogers-Lape-Huffman-Larzelere-DeWitt-Veon-Shetler-France (1853-?), who collected eight surnames, ran at least six businesses, was arrested multiple times, and built an economic empire in the only industry that would let a 19th-century woman be her own boss.
History called her immoral. She called herself a businesswoman.
Both were probably right.