11/05/2025
"I swing between happiness and misery. I am part prude and part nonconformist. I say what I think and I don't pretend and I am prepared to accept the consequences of my actions."
Vivien Leigh
– November 5, 1913
Does Vivien Leigh have a spot in the pantheon of Gay Icons? She certainly brought the talent and the melodrama. She was more beautiful, had more gay friends, was just as much a bitch, and was as high strung and promiscuous as Joan Crawford or Bette Davis.
Crawford and Davis had the attributes of many gay guys of their era: scrappy, ambitious, lack of self-pity, high standards in how to live and dress. They struggled with finding respect despite talent and drive. They had family problems, and nothing close to a traditional love life or home life. They were not afraid or apologetic about using their wit and their smarts. They didn't suffer fools gladly. They possessed vulnerability and strength. They remain perfect Gay Icons. Poor Leigh was just a tiny, lovely, fragile woman with severe mental illness.
GONE WITH THE WIND (1939) brought Leigh fame and an Oscar; but she told the press: "I'm not a film star; I'm an actress. Being a film star – just a film star – is such a false life, lived for fake values and for publicity. Actresses go on for years and years."
In 1967, Leigh was struck with a recurrence of tuberculosis, an illness that had plagued her for 25 years. Her final credits rolled a few months later, just before MGM was launching the sixth national release of GONE WITH THE WIND, by then, the most popular and biggest money-making film of all time. Leigh received $20,000 ($450,000 in 2025 dollars) for her work in GWTW. She later ruefully said: "I wouldn't have objected to just a little bit of the percentage of the film's income."
Maybe Leigh is not a top Gay Icon because she didn't invent a public personality the same way Garland, Davis and Crawford did. Plus, Leigh wasn't naturally funny. Davis, Crawford and Garland could be funny.
1941 portrait by Cecil Beaton