04/20/2026
THIS IS ABSOLUTELY INSANE.
Real talk. I have seen businesses come and go here in Titusville. I myself own a private tattoo studio downtown and I have no words. This kind of behavior is nasty and I am so glad that I have gotten to know Sam and Jordan over at the The Goat and can tell you they are some of the NICEST HUMANS on this earth.
I know all businesses aren’t going to see eye to eye, but we will stand next to you, support you, and I’ll be damned to sit back and not speak up about this one.
A sincere shoutout to every pizzeria that has opened in Titusville since we did.
We mean that genuinely.
Being an entrepreneur takes courage.
Opening a restaurant takes everything you have. And doing it in a community that already has a 42-year institution serving over 1,000 customers a week? That takes some serious confidence. We respect it.
Nick has said it publicly and he'll say it again: the independent pizzerias of Titusville all deserve your support. Rising tides lift all boats. Competition makes everyone better — including us.
But here's where we have to be honest with you, Titusville.
There is one title that simply cannot be handed out to a newcomer. One distinction that is earned exclusively through time, consistency, and decades of trust built one pizza, one family, one memory at a time.
The GOAT — the Greatest of All Time — requires all that time.
We were here when you were in Little League. We were here when your parents brought you for your first slice. We were here for first dates that became marriages, and for children who were named Kelsey because of the memories made inside these walls. We were here for the hard years, the good years, and every Friday night in between — since November 26, 1983.
So we say this with nothing but love and Maximum Respect for everyone in this market:
There can only be one GOAT.
You already know where to find us. 2845 Garden St, Titusville
Maximum Respect!
