11/13/2025
COLUMBUS, OH - There is a point, somewhere between your third loop around a city and your fifteenth carefully plotted detour, when you realize that the thing you are searching for is not a singular arrival, but an accumulation of exciting mini destinations. Columbus, I suspect, will be that kind of journey for me, a long courtship with a city determined to keep its best work tucked behind unassuming storefronts and half-lit plazas. The tours have been… earnest so far, a little bruising, occasionally mid. But faith is an odd companion, and it tends to reward those who keep showing up hungry.
One of the true rewards was Donna’s Delicious Dozen, a small donut outpost at 5322 N Hamilton Rd, where the air smells like warm sugar and the gentle hiss of frying batter is practically a welcome mat. I love desserts with the kind of fervor that borders on addiction, especially the ones that involve cake textures and chocolate. But perhaps because of that devotion, I am an unforgiving critic. Dessert should not merely be sweet; it should be intentional. If I am going to risk my lifespan on something fried, glazed, or swirled, it should be worth the sacrifice.
Donna’s understood this.
I ordered a half dozen, a modest number that felt, in the moment, almost polite. But politeness evaporates when I’m watching these mini donuts being piped, fried, flipped, and ornamented just feet from where I was standing. Each one emerged warm, buttery, and carrying an aroma that makes you briefly forget your troubles for that one second. That first bite was all that mattered, revealing pronounced notes of butter, vanilla, and an undertow of nuttiness braided into a texture that was tender yet structured, dense in a way that feels intentional rather than heavy. The crumb is moist, but the donut is shockingly un-oily, a rarity in the world of made-to-order cake donuts that will leave your hands glistening.
The toppings did not fight the donut. They amplify it. Choose the flavors you love, truly, any of them, and you’ll find that the base donut is so well-executed it makes every topping taste like it was designed in collaboration.
But the real surprise came the next morning.
Most cake donuts collapse within 24 hours into small edible bricks that are stiff, stale, and occasionally better suited for self-defense than breakfast. Thus far, we are experts in that area in the city. Donna’s donuts did not. Day two, they were still tender, still aromatic, still worthy of contemplation. No greasiness. No rubbery resistance. Just a soft, slightly crumbly interior that suggested a baker who understands both chemistry and care.
If you’re anywhere near Columbus, and honestly, even if you’re not, this is worth a short trip. Call them at (614) 245-4859 and treat yourself to something that feels like the city shouting, “See? I told you there were gems here.”