
23/03/2025
🎬🎬 Sebastián Lelio's Disobedience (2017) is a poignant and deeply intimate exploration of love, freedom, and faith. Set within the confines of an Orthodox Jewish community in London, the film is a layered examination of the struggle between personal desires and societal expectations. Adapted from Naomi Alderman's novel, the story revolves around Ronit (Rachel Weisz), a woman estranged from her conservative upbringing, who returns home following her father's death. Her reappearance rekindles a forbidden romance with her childhood friend Esti (Rachel McAdams), who is now married to Dovid (Alessandro Nivola), a respected rabbi and Ronit's cousin.
Weisz and McAdams deliver stunning performances, their chemistry pulsating with longing and restraint. Weisz portrays Ronit’s defiant, questioning nature with sensitivity, while McAdams embodies Esti’s quiet turmoil with grace. Alessandro Nivola, too, is remarkable, adding complexity to Dovid's conflict between faith and compassion.
Lelio’s direction is meticulous, with an emphasis on silence and small gestures that convey unspoken emotions. The muted cinematography by Danny Cohen adds to the film's melancholic tone, reflecting the characters’ suppressed emotions and the suffocating rigidity of their environment.
The narrative is compelling, but it’s the emotional depth and moral complexity that stand out. The film doesn’t vilify faith or tradition but instead explores how individuals navigate their identities within them. The central love story is treated with care and respect, offering a nuanced portrayal of q***r relationships rarely seen on screen.
Disobedience is a slow-burning yet profoundly moving film. It captures the pain of living a life bound by duty and the courage it takes to embrace love and authenticity, even at great personal cost. A must-watch for those who appreciate thoughtful, character-driven dramas.