05/28/2026
What Spruance Did After Nimitz Overruled Him
5:14 in the morning, February 17th, 1944. The deck of USS New Jersey. Somewhere in the central Pacific Ocean, Raymond Spruent stood at the railing and watched the western sky. 74 Hellcat fighters had just lifted off from the carrier force and climbed into the darkness ahead. One by one, they disappeared.
There was nothing left to watch, just the sound of the wind across open water and 669 nautical miles between him and what he had just set in motion. Here is what you need to understand about that moment. 8 weeks earlier, this same man had sat in a conference room at Pearl Harbor and told Chester Nimttz that his plan was dangerous, reckless.
That was the word he used. Turner agreed. Holland Smith agreed. Three men, three times, one word. Nimttz overruled all three. That campaign was over in four days. And now, the man who called it reckless, was standing on the deck of a battleship in the dark before sunrise, having just ordered simultaneous attacks on two targets nearly 700 m apart.
Same week, same moment. No American admiral had ever done that before him. And within 48 hours, his own staff would use that same word for him. Reckless, same word, same man. Two different decisions. He never explained the difference to anyone. This story begins on February 4th, the day Spruent first stepped aboard this ship.
It ends on February 23rd, the day both of those parallel campaigns were finished. Each one in its own way erased something the Japanese had spent years building and almost no one at home knew it was happening. Not because it was kept secret, because it was over too fast to become a story. If you've been with this channel for a while, you know we don't tell the easy ones.
If this one feels like it's worth your time, I like helps it find the people who need to hear it. Not for us, for the men in it. Now, let's go back to February 4th and the reason Spruent chose this particular ship. When Raymond Spruent took command of the Central Pacific Force in November of 1943, one of the first decisions he made was a quiet one. Nobody announced it.
Nobody reported on it. Most people who worked for him probably didn't give it a second thought. He decided he would not use a battleship as his flagship. The reasoning was simple. The battleships available for fleet es**rt in 1943, the North Carolina class, the South Dakota class, could make about 27 knots at full speed.
A fleet carrier doing the same run could do 33. If your flagship has to keep pace with the battle line, you are always slower than the fastest ships you command. Spruent couldn't afford that. He chose USS Indianapolis instead. a heavy cruiser, faster, more maneuverable, better suited to keeping pace with the carriers he was responsible for.
He used Indianapolis through the Gilbert Islands, through the planning months for the Marshals, through Quadrilene, 14 months. Then on February 4th, 1944 at Majuro Atal, the deep water anchorage in the eastern marshals that the Navy had seized and converted into a forward base in a matter of days. Spruent transferred his flag to USS New Jersey, Iowa class battleship, the longest, heaviest warship the United States Navy had ever put to sea. 887 ft from bow to stern.
A crew of nearly 2,000 men, many of them seeing their first action. The ship herself was barely 14 months old. Commissioned in May of 1943 through the Panama Canal in January of 1944 into the Pacific in time to screen the carriers during the Quadrilane operation and nine 16-in guns.