10/08/2024
One of Orange County’s oldest and most historic structures, the 1841 stagecoach stop known as The Maples, has been designated by Saving Historic Orange County (SHOC) as the next candidate for protection offered by a listing on the National Register of Historic Places.
SHOC’s proposal to finance cost of the National Register project received the blessing of The Maples owner, Kelly Cuff. Work begins this week to prepare an application, which will be reviewed first by Indiana Division of Historic Preservation and Archaeology (DHPA). If approved, the paperwork moves on to the National Park Service in Washington D.C., which administers National Register of Historic Places.
This week, Kurt West Garner, of Heritage Preservation, Plymouth, IN will visit the historic inn, which offered travelers lodging on the stagecoach route between New Albany and Vincennes. The property, located between Paoli and West Baden Springs, was built by James Campbell and served as an inn for many decades.
Mr. Garner is acquainted with Orange County and SHOC. He was contracted by the preservation group and successfully nominated the Shindler-Stetson House in Orleans to the National Register in 2021. He is a renowned historic preservation consultant, who has prepared more successful National Register nominations than any other consultant in the state of Indiana.
Mr. Garner told SHOC members he is excited to begin work on the nomination of The Maples. The original iron bar securing the door to the room where cash was stored, remains in place in the house and the summer kitchen, smoke house, barn, corn crib and carriage house, all remaining on the property. He is hopeful those surviving structures will allow the property a unique and uncommon listing on the Register as a farmstead.
Members of SHOC had noticed restoration occurring in a preservationist’s manner to the inn exterior and chose Mr. Cuff recipient of the organization’s annual Historic Preservation award.
During the award selection process, members expressed concern about protection of the historic property, especially considering its proximity to a SR 56 and US 150. National Register properties are offered a degree of protection should proposed state or federal projects diminish or threaten its historic value, so SHOC moved forward toward the National Register nomination by contracting Mr. Garner.
In addition to protection, a listing on the National Register of Historic Places allows the property owner the ability to qualify for either state or federal tax credits for approved restoration projects, an added benefit for Mr. Cuff.
Pictured below: Owner of The Maples, Kelly Cuff, center, is recipient of the 2024 Saving Historic Orange County (SHOC) preservation award. Jeff Lane, SHOC member and Orange County Historian, made the presentation with SHOC president, Terry Cornwell. Mr. Cuff is the twelfth owner of historic Orange County property to be recognized for preservation efforts by SHOC.