Mountain State Mysteries

Mountain State Mysteries A West Virginia true crime podcast that digs into mysteries of the Mountain State and beyond.
(1)

A woman born in Beckley, West Virginia, is scheduled to be executed in Tennessee in six days. Christa Gail Pike was 18 y...
09/23/2026

A woman born in Beckley, West Virginia, is scheduled to be executed in Tennessee in six days.

Christa Gail Pike was 18 years old and attending a Job Corps program in Knoxville when she became convinced that 19-year-old Colleen Slemmer was interested in her boyfriend, Tadaryl Shipp.

On January 12, 1995, Pike, Shipp and another student, Shadolla Peterson, led Colleen to a secluded area near the University of Tennessee’s agricultural campus. What followed was a prolonged and brutal attack that ended with Colleen’s death.

Pike was convicted of first-degree murder and conspiracy to commit murder. In 1996, she was sentenced to death. Shipp, who was 17 when the crime occurred, received a life sentence. Peterson cooperated with prosecutors and pleaded guilty to being an accessory after the fact.

Now 50 years old, Pike is the only woman on Tennessee’s death row. Her ex*****on is scheduled for September 30, 2026. If it proceeds, she will become the first woman executed by the state in more than 200 years.

Pike’s attorneys have requested clemency from Tennessee Governor Bill Lee, asking that her sentence be changed to life in prison without parole. They cite her age at the time of the murder, history of severe childhood abuse, mental health conditions and decades spent in isolation. The courts have repeatedly upheld her conviction and death sentence.

At the center of every debate surrounding this case is Colleen Slemmer, a 19-year-old woman whose life was taken in an unimaginably cruel way.

Should Pike’s sentence be carried out, or should it be reduced to life without the possibility of parole?

New River Gorge National Park and Preserve is known for its towering cliffs, rushing whitewater, peaceful trails and som...
09/22/2026

New River Gorge National Park and Preserve is known for its towering cliffs, rushing whitewater, peaceful trails and some of the most diverse forestland in the country. Established as a national river in 1978 and redesignated as a national park and preserve in 2020, it welcomes visitors from across the country each year.

Behind its breathtaking scenery, however, is a vast and rugged wilderness. Over the years, people have disappeared within and around the park. Some were rescued, while others were tragically found deceased.

One of those individuals was George Andrew Gross.

On January 12, 2018, the 56-year-old retired firefighter and United States Marine Corps veteran was visiting Beckley, West Virginia. He contacted a family member and said he was considering a hike in or around New River Gorge. That would be the last time his family heard from him.

After Gross was reported missing, multiple agencies joined the search. His truck was discovered late Monday night at the Fern Creek trailhead, leading crews to concentrate on the nearby trails, cliffs and wooded terrain.

The following day, searchers found Gross’s body near the Diamond Point area, more than two miles from the trailhead. Officials said the cause and manner of his death remained under investigation.

Rangers from New River Gorge National River assisted the West Virginia State Police during the search. The Fayette County Sheriff’s Office K-9 Unit, Fayette County Vertical Rescue Team, Fayetteville Fire Department and Jan-Care Ambulance Service were also involved.

Gross was more than a missing hiker. He was a husband, father, veteran and respected firefighter who had devoted much of his life to serving others.

Our thoughts remain with the family and friends of George Andrew Gross.

What began with a suspicious encounter near Independence Hall has grown into one of the most disturbing investigations c...
09/21/2026

What began with a suspicious encounter near Independence Hall has grown into one of the most disturbing investigations currently unfolding in the country.

In June, federal park rangers encountered 44-year-old Eugene Horsch inside a vehicle parked in an area reserved for law enforcement. Authorities allege they discovered fi****ms with obliterated serial numbers, drugs, false federal credentials and an identification card connected to a missing woman.

The investigation led police to Horsch’s home on Chew Avenue, which he previously shared with his late father, photographer and filmmaker Raymond “R.C.” Horsch.

According to investigators, searches of the property uncovered chemicals, urns containing cremated remains and more than one million digital images and videos. Authorities have identified 58 people within those files, including seven women who remain missing. Some of the material reportedly appears to show several of those women unconscious or possibly deceased.

The FBI is assisting investigators as they continue examining the enormous collection of evidence. Only a portion of the files has reportedly been reviewed.

Eugene Horsch remains in custody on federal weapons charges. At this time, he has not been charged with causing the disappearance or death of any woman, and investigators have not announced the discovery of any bodies inside the home.

This remains an active and rapidly developing investigation. We will continue following updates as authorities work to determine what happened inside the Chew Avenue property and, most importantly, what happened to the missing women connected to it.

Have you been following the Eugene Horsch investigation?

09/21/2026

👀 OKAY Y’ALL… WE’RE ASKING AGAIN!

We mentioned this before, but we seriously want to know who would be down for a Mountain State Mysteries WATCH PARTY?! 🍿🔍

Earlier this year, we got the incredible opportunity to be featured on Sleeping With a Killer, and now that our episodes are officially out, we thought… why not watch them together?!

We’re thinking about hosting an in-person MSM Watch Party where we’d watch an episode or two of Sleeping With a Killer featuring cases we helped tell.

🎟️ Tickets would be available for purchase
🍿 Light refreshments and snacks included
🎬 Watch the episodes together
🎙️ Hang out with Mark & Courtney
🔍 And maybe talk a little more about the cases and what it was like being part of the show!

But before we start putting everything together, we need to know if the Mystery Crew would actually come!

So tell us below 👇

WHO WOULD COME TO AN MSM WATCH PARTY?! 🖤💛

If we get enough interest… we might just have to make this happen. 👀

In 1992, a 19-year-old woman in Charleston, West Virginia, fought for her life against a man she had tried to help.Years...
09/21/2026

In 1992, a 19-year-old woman in Charleston, West Virginia, fought for her life against a man she had tried to help.

Years later, she would learn she had survived an encounter with a serial killer.

On May 13, 1992, Fabienne Witherspoon was walking to a friend’s apartment when she encountered a young man beneath a bridge who appeared to be asking for food. Feeling compassion for him, Fabienne offered to bring him food and clothing from the apartment.

That man was Tommy Lynn Sells.

While Fabienne gathered food, Sells entered the apartment and armed himself with a knife. He confronted her from behind, locked the door and forced her into the bathroom.

Fabienne initially tried to comply, hoping she could survive the encounter and that he would eventually leave. But when Sells allegedly told her he intended to sexually assault her, something changed.

She fought.

Fabienne grabbed a ceramic decoration from the bathroom and repeatedly struck Sells with it. During the struggle, she managed to gain control of the knife and stabbed him multiple times.

Sells fought back, striking Fabienne in the head with a piano stool and leaving her seriously injured.

But Fabienne survived.

Sells was also badly wounded. His injuries ultimately led him to a hospital, where he was taken into police custody. Fabienne suffered a severe head wound and an injury to her hand that required surgery.

At the time, authorities had no idea who they were dealing with.

Sells eventually pleaded guilty to malicious wounding and served approximately five years in prison.

Only later would his name become associated with a horrifying series of murders across the United States.

Four months after his 1997 release from prison, 10-year-old Joel Kirkpatrick was murdered inside his Illinois home. Joel’s mother, Julie Rea, said she encountered an intruder that night and fought with him, but investigators eventually focused their attention on her.

Rea was convicted of killing her son and sentenced to 65 years in prison.

Years later, while Sells was on death row in Texas for another murder, he confessed to killing a young boy in Illinois and described details that became significant to Rea’s defense. Her original conviction had already been overturned, and during a second trial in 2006, Sells’ confession became part of her defense. Prosecutors disputed the confession and continued to maintain that Rea was responsible.

A jury found Rea not guilty. She later received a certificate of innocence from the State of Illinois.

Sells was never formally charged with Joel’s murder.

He was executed by lethal injection in Texas in 2014.

For Fabienne, discovering the true identity of the man she fought in Charleston brought complicated emotions. She has spoken publicly about survivor’s guilt and wondering whether anything more could have been done to prevent the violence that followed.

But one fact remains extraordinary.

At just 19 years old, Fabienne Witherspoon found herself trapped inside an apartment with a violent attacker.

She fought back.

And she survived.

Her story is a chilling piece of West Virginia true crime history, and one that deserves to be remembered for more than the name of the man who attacked her.

It is also the story of the young woman who refused to let him take her life.

95 Years Ago This Weekend: The Mob That Came for Harry PowersIn September 1931, thousands of people surrounded the Harri...
09/20/2026

95 Years Ago This Weekend: The Mob That Came for Harry Powers

In September 1931, thousands of people surrounded the Harrison County Jail in Clarksburg, demanding that accused murderer Harry Powers be turned over to them.

Authorities used fire hoses and tear gas to push back the crowd. Powers was later moved to the West Virginia Penitentiary in Moundsville for his protection.

Powers, known as the “Bluebeard of Quiet Dell,” used lonely-hearts advertisements to meet women. He was ultimately convicted of murdering Dorothy Lemke after five victims were discovered buried near his Quiet Dell property. He was executed by hanging in 1932.

The case became one of the darkest and most infamous chapters in West Virginia history.

Had you ever heard about the massive crowd that gathered outside the jail?

The Mothman Festival brings together believers, skeptics, paranormal investigators, and lovers of all things strange to ...
09/19/2026

The Mothman Festival brings together believers, skeptics, paranormal investigators, and lovers of all things strange to celebrate one of West Virginia’s most iconic mysteries.

From the towering Mothman statue and fascinating guest speakers to local vendors, incredible costumes, and a trip through the TNT area, there’s something mysterious waiting around every corner.

Who’s heading to Point Pleasant for the Mothman Festival? And the real question is, do you believe the legend? 👀

In the summer of 1995, 17-year-old Miki Ann “Miki” Koontz appeared to have a bright future ahead of her. The Williamson ...
09/19/2026

In the summer of 1995, 17-year-old Miki Ann “Miki” Koontz appeared to have a bright future ahead of her. The Williamson High School student was known as a homecoming queen, cheerleader, and strong student who was preparing to begin college at Marshall University.

Behind the scenes, however, Miki had struggled with drug addiction and had recently returned home after completing a rehabilitation program. Just three days later, on August 25, 1995, she left home after telling her mother she needed to run a few errands before they planned to attend a football game together. She never returned.

According to court testimony, Miki was lured to a remote wooded area near Williamson, where she was fatally shot. Investigators alleged that the killing was connected to a drug operation, and one man later admitted in court to carrying out the shooting, claiming he had been threatened and forced to do so to satisfy a drug debt. As part of a plea agreement, he agreed to testify against the individual prosecutors identified as the alleged leader of the drug operation. That individual later pleaded guilty to federal drug conspiracy charges but was never charged in Miki’s murder.

Miki’s body was discovered three days later, on what should have been her first day of classes at Marshall University. Her death devastated the Williamson community, where she was remembered as a kind, outgoing young woman with dreams of becoming either a lawyer or a journalist.

Her case remains a heartbreaking reminder of the devastating impact drugs can have on young lives, families, and entire communities.

Do you remember when this case happened, or have you heard Miki’s story before? Share your memories or thoughts respectfully in the comments.

On Wednesday, March 16, 2016, deputies were contacted by Metro Communications and asked to meet with Pamela Wade, who re...
09/18/2026

On Wednesday, March 16, 2016, deputies were contacted by Metro Communications and asked to meet with Pamela Wade, who reported she had been unable to reach her son, Marshall Priestley. She told authorities she had not seen or heard from him since late February of that year.

Wade explained that Priestley attended a custody hearing on February 29, 2016. After meeting with his attorney, he took money to his daughter, Michaela Priestley, at her workplace. Wade stated that the last communication she personally had with her son was through text messages on February 28. After he delivered the money to his daughter, he was not heard from again.

Worried about his safety, Wade went to his home at 105 Christian Road in Cross Lanes, Kanawha County, West Virginia, but was unable to reach him. Deputies also went to the residence but could not locate Priestley or make contact with anyone inside. While checking the surrounding area, officers spoke with neighbors. One neighbor reported not seeing Priestley for several weeks and expressed concern that something may have happened to him.

Several months after he was reported missing, a fire destroyed his home on Christian Road. Authorities have not determined whether the fire is connected to his disappearance.

Mr. Priestley has several identifying tattoos, including:
• A full sleeve on his right arm featuring imagery related to the Grateful Dead
• A tattoo of a Grateful Dead guitar on his lower right leg
• A design across his shoulder blades that includes the name “Brandi,” a male face, and female eyes
• Lettering tattooed across his lower back
• A scar on his left forearm from a workplace injury that was later covered with a tattoo of a Native American figure

Marshall Priestley was entered into the National Crime Information Center database as a missing person under entry number M923134757.

Anyone with information is asked to contact the Kanawha County Sheriff’s Office Criminal Investigation Section at 304-357-0556.

Y’all, we’ve been keeping this one quiet, but we can FINALLY share! 📺💛Earlier this year, we were contacted to appear on ...
09/17/2026

Y’all, we’ve been keeping this one quiet, but we can FINALLY share! 📺💛

Earlier this year, we were contacted to appear on Sleeping with a Killer, and the episodes featuring us are officially out!

Having the opportunity to bring more attention to local cases means so much to us. We’re grateful to be part of sharing these stories and keeping the people at the heart of them from being forgotten.

So, Mystery Crew… should we host a watch party? 👀 We’d love to watch with y’all, share our experience, and talk more about the local cases featured.

Let us know in the comments if you’d join us! 🖤💛

Address

Parkersburg, WV
26101, 26102, 26103, 26104, 26105, 26106

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Mountain State Mysteries posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category