12/08/2025
The recent publication of the U.S. National Security Strategy under the Trump administration draws attention to the civilizational crisis of the Western world. Nowhere is this felt more keenly than among various factions of the ruling elite, who are confronted by the dead end of their own historical epoch.
With this in mind we share an essay by Nuri Yi for Issue 1 of our journal, published in 2023.
"The terms of civilization and modernity are serious and mighty; they carry this weight because they are the birthright of the masses who make up the majority of humankind and have toiled for thousands of years to build civilization—an advanced stage of human development that produces a way of life. Civilization must be protected because it captures an essential current of humanity and its progress. It is thus a category that has a place together with History: the long arc of human history from past to present, with continuity and movement forward. Civilization, though related to History, is a distinct category with new dimensions and meaning. Beyond the materialist stages of history conceptualized by Marx and Engels, civilization considers the qualitative development of human morality, ideas, philosophy, and culture. It points back to our ancestors and the link from them to where we find ourselves today, to the future of our children’s children, and asks: how did we get here?
"In this time, civilization cannot be left as an abstract idea for detached academics or elites to pessimistically problematize or deconstruct, severing the concept from its source. The stakes are indeed high, but the concept of civilization has been thrust in our faces, demanding to be worked out, put into practice, and fought for. The discussion is clearly ongoing: it has not yet been entirely decided as to what extent civilization will be an assertion of the past, with the objective being return to a previous status quo, or an assertion for the future, with the objective being genuine human progress. It is up to the people of the world to weld civilization into the latter.
"The American people, too, must take up the question of civilization: what will its meaning be to us, and what will our contribution be to it? Given that America is so young, these concepts may on the surface seem relevant to Americans only insofar as other civilizations might encroach on or threaten our way of life. However, the current crisis of American society—a crisis of legitimacy in the midst of poverty and war—compels us to find a lifeline that can lead us to the future and help us to reestablish our proper place in the world. The call for “civilization,” whether in America or anywhere else, provides a self-conscious category that demands unity and purpose in the continuous struggle for human advance. Thinkers of the Black Freedom Movement saw this possibility the most clearly: they saw civilization in the modern age as a double-edged sword which could be used to either uphold a sterile and doomed system of white supremacy, or decisively pierce through this system to dismantle it for a greater human freedom.
"The concept of civilization declares that this future must carry the old but reflect something new, providing a continuous link to history while simultaneously transcending previous achievements. Today in America, a young country with history still to make, a healthy understanding of civilization and its responsibilities can give depth and voice to the discontented. It can double the voice of the American people calling for an end to poverty, inequality, and war by linking their aspirations to those of the world’s people, who seek democracy of opportunity for advancement. America’s and the world’s people must be freed from the imperialist order to establish equality amongst civilizations."
A generation ago, America’s revolutionary thinkers put forward a new theory of civilization.