10/10/2025
A Paragould lawyer has filed a motion to dismiss an appeal from Jefferson County Judge Gerald Robinson of an order by a special county judge to have her and her firm compensated for prior representation.
Kimberly Dale of the Branch & Thompson law firm filed a motion to dismiss and strike an Aug. 1 appeal from Robinson, whose lawyer appealed in a July 30 letter to special county judge Efrem Neely Sr. that Neely's appointment was limited to presiding over a case and that ordering vouchers for payment fell outside his scope.
Neely, who was appointed special county judge by Gov. Sarah Huckabee Sanders for a case heard July 1, issued a ruling July 29 that Jefferson County Clerk Shawndra Taggart collect all outstanding invoices from the law firm for his approval and signature.
Eleventh West Circuit Judge Rob Wyatt on Aug. 4 ordered a stay of that ruling. Dale represented several individual justices of the peace in a legal battle that began on July 14, 2023, regarding the validity of Quorum Court meetings without an active ordinance and ended with a ruling in Robinson's favor filed Jan. 6 of this year.
In the motion filed Wednesday, Dale argues Robinson's appeal is "wholly without merit and should be dismissed pursuant to Arkansas Rules of Civil Procedure, Rule 12 and Rule 19." According to the suit, Neely indicated in a July 31 email to the county clerk, Robinson's lawyer Casey Castleberry of North Little Rock, and governor's office representative Lori Jordan that Robinson was not a party to the County Court matter. Jordan reportedly stated: "Upon his recusal, Judge Robinson ceased to be a party of interest, and concerns of conflict of interest should have been raised prior to the hearing if they were genuine. Their emergency only after an adverse ruling casts doubt on their merit."
A Paragould lawyer has filed a motion to dismiss an appeal from Jefferson County Judge Gerald Robinson of an order by a special county judge to have her and her firm compensated for prior representation.