12/19/2025
Castle Blood
The Christmas Witches
Monessen, PA
December 12, 2025
Every year at about this time, Lily and I end up in a conversation that goes something like this:
Innocent Bystander: Bet you two are sad now that Halloween’s over. What do you do for the holidays?
Tish and Lily: Oh, we go to Christmas haunts.
Innocent Bystander: What? Christmas haunts? How do you do a haunted house at Christmastime? WHY would you do a haunted house at Christmastime??
Lily (sighing, rolling her eyes, bracing herself for what comes next): ...
Tish (clearing her throat, adjusting her glasses): Well, ACTUALLY, this is the perfect time of year for haunted houses. Let me explain…
This season is in fact the ideal time to commune with ghoulies and ghosties and long-leggedy beasties. The nights are dark and long; the veil is thin. Plus, ghosts and monsters are a huge part of the seasonal spice – one of the most beloved tales of this holiday involves a bitter, lonely man who is haunted by spirits and hounded by visions of his own death. Dickens’ classic tale is both chilling and cheery, menacing and merry…and that’s a blend that Castle Blood in Monessen, Pennsylvania understands very well.
The story behind Castle Blood is that a motley crew of monsters from the Old World have washed up on the shores of the Mon and made their home in an old funeral parlor. A few times a year, the Castle’s denizens open the doors of their home to welcome mortal guests and to their various holiday traditions. Because these exchanges are never free, the human visitors have to solve a series of puzzles and collect several talismans to secure safe passage through the Castle. You can also count on the Castle for a good story – the journey is part of a narrative, made up of folklore, popular culture, and the Castle’s own wacky mythology.
The Christmas – excuse me, CRYPTMAS – version of the tour is always a bit more family-friendly. In fact, when Lily and I went through, there were plenty of wide-eyed kiddos waiting to enter the cobweb-hung halls. In deference to all the young guests, the puzzles are a bit easier and the denizens are a bit more forgiving. Heck, you even get a helpful, printed list of the talismans that you’re searching for! Also, the atmosphere is a bit more playful, although guests can expect to have their wits and their nerves tested by the creatures who dwell within. This year’s wintry tour offered a spin on the witchy tale the Castle has been weaving for the past year, but instead of seeking out Maiden, Mother, and Crone (or Sabrina, Deirdre, and Brigid), guests interact with the witches’ Yuletide incarnations: Pepper, Sugar, and Ginger. The talismans that we must collect also give a nod to beloved holiday traditions and figures. This event balances creepy and cozy (much like Dickens’ beloved story) – and, like Dickens, it teaches a lesson too.
In shadow or snow, the Castle looks great. The denizens may not understand this whole Christmas thing, but they certainly don’t skimp on decoration. There are trees, lights, and garland everywhere. Gingerdead Lane (usually the Castle cemetery) is a Victorian fantasia of red and white. It’s a beautifully Gothic take on the holiday. If you get a chance, linger in the hallways and savor the details.
The puzzles are a wee bit less punishing than usual, but they’re varied and clever. We have to participate in a game of ring toss (relying heavily on Lily’s high school softball skills), exercise some logic, and witness some up-close and personal magic. Any tour through the Castle is also highly referential: one puzzle shows us what the Island of Misfit Toys has in common with the “Conjuring” universe. (It’s smart and unexpectedly sinister.) We are called upon to think, observe, and work together with all the members of our group to ensure our survival. (Oh, I forgot to mention – in the spirit of the season, there’s a powerful emphasis on good will to all.)
As always, the format of the tour offers plenty of opportunities for the denizens to exercise their acting skills. Each group spends two to three minutes in each room of the Castle, solving puzzles and bantering with the various creatures. The show starts on the Castle’s wraparound porch with Astrid – excuse me, Vixen – belting twisted versions of Christmas carols. Professor Ezra, doddering and sweet, offers us warnings and rules. Kind Lady Die greets us in the parlor and tells us the story while the elegant young vampire in the caretaker’s office sets us on our way. Have you ever wondered what it would be like to work for vampires? Well, poor, stoic Loomis has discovered that employment may last beyond the grave, and he’ll NEVER get that promotion he so richly deserves. Vibrant Varvara meets us in the study (where the taxidermy is bedecked with tinsel and twinkling lights) to pose another challenge and to laugh at our failures. We are delighted to see the fabulous fortuneteller Ivan Seeyou whose creaky voice and glamorous style are surpassed only by his soothsaying skills. Annatoli, deadpan and patient, presides over the Castle’s gorgeous steampunk laboratory. We meet the first of the Christmas Witches deep in the bowels of the Castle when playful, prickly Pepper poses a problem. Gruff Thorgrim offers us safe passage through the catacombs. Sassy Sugar tries to share some of her grace with us; alas, everyone in our group has two left feet. Professor Scrye is a man of science, but apparently, he shares some DNA (and some cursed objects) with Ed and Lorraine Warren. Gen X-ers might recognize Chris the Christmas Warlock from a certain Rankin-Bass special, but he helps us put one foot in front of another as we navigate the cemetery. The adorable Ginger might sound like Hexibart but she is cute as a button and sweet as, well, as gingerbread. Motherly Phoebe pronounces her gentle judgment on all of us before sending us out into the night. These performers are charming and assured, comfortable in their roles and in their interactions with guests.
This version of Castle Blood is, like Dickens’ timeless tale, funny, scary, sweet, and meaningful. Maybe you don’t have time to fly through the night skies with three different ghosts; well, you’ll have as much fun – and learn as much – with the denizens of Castle Blood.
Cost: $25
Other stuff to do: There are photo ops outside the Castle and in Gingerdead Lane. The Castle also runs a gift shop with Castle-branded apparel, ornaments, and original art.
Other stuff to know: Because the tours focus on collaborative puzzle-solving, you go through in a group of about 5.