11/05/2025
Crawford School of Terror
Over 18 Night
Connellsville, PA
November 1, 2025
Back when I was in college, one of my Halloween rituals was going to see Rocky Horror on Friday nights. My friends and I threw toast and toilet paper and yelled dirty jokes at the screen. We laughed and screamed and (in the words of the movie’s main character) gave ourselves over to absolute pleasure. It was vulgar. It was a little scary. It was a lot of fun.
Now, imagine that you are not going to see Rocky Horror; imagine instead that you’re in it. Your car has broken down outside a looming abandoned schoolhouse and you have to seek shelter for the night. Imagine that you’re dragged inside by a pair of guys in gimp masks and placed at the mercy of the funny, creepy, oversexed, unhinged maniacs that dwell in these dark halls. That’s Over 18 Night at Crawford School of Terror.
During most of the Halloween season, Crawford School is diabolically dark, an exercise in pure terror. But for one night, the monsters let their ids out to play. With Over 18 Night, the hauntrunners at Crawford have crafted a HIGHLY interactive adventure that’s filthy and funny. Guests are invited – nay, required – to participate in a range of scenes. At the start of the evening, you’re given a prop bag that includes several objects you might need throughout your journey, including money that will allow you to buy your way out of one challenge. But with that one safeguard aside, all bets are off. You may have to swallow something nasty, crawl on all fours, stick your hand into a body cavity, or bark like a dog. The innuendos and insults are constant; the challenges are ribald and gross. (You should know what you’re in for when you see that your prop bag includes a condom and a baby wipe.) Bring a sense of humor and leave your fancy clothes (and your inhibitions and your dignity) at home.
If you’re a haunt enthusiast, this post-season romp will give you a chance to appreciate the design at Crawford School of Terror, the claustrophobic corridors, the winding paths, the halls hung with pages ripped from books or covered with stuffed animals. Long stretches of the building are still spine-chilling. One of the members of our group alternated between yelling “No” and “EFF NO” at the eerie collection of toys in the decrepit daycare. (This is not the place to visit if you have a fear of haunted dolls.) Honestly, Lily and I TRIED to pay attention to the clever layout of the rooms, the exquisitely dreadful details. But that’s a little hard to do when you’re being ordered to drop to your knees and take a shot of some suspiciously thick white liquid “like a good girl.”
The School sticks (sort of) to its regular themes. The health teacher has some vital lessons to impart, for example. As you pick your way through the halls, you have to help the science teacher with her experiments; you may be asked to try the lunch lady’s latest concoction. The janitor needs some assistance in the restroom while the school nurse needs to conduct a thorough examination, and the VICE principal has some punishments to dole out. But wait! There's more! Lily and I are forced to participate in a, um, hands-on group project. There's also a deranged shop teacher and an administrator who has his mind on bodies other than the student body. The performances are laugh-out-loud funny and completely feral. The monsters clearly enjoy this chance to stretch their muscles; the format allows them to banter and improvise. It also allows them to torment the dumb humans at their mercy. (Gomez still isn’t sure how he ended up in the stirrups, but I think he enjoyed it.) The scenes are immersive but briskly paced, offering little down time between the dizzying, demented encounters.
Down in the basement, the Over 18 theme allows Meemaw and her kids to really cut loose. These backwoods cannibals were born for events like this. There’s a creepy scene where two of her in**ed children alternate lust and violence, while her oldest son just wants to make some friends. Don’t bother to ask him his name – he’ll grin, stick out a paw and say, “Don’t rightly know. Meemaw always calls me F**kin’ Ugly!” Meemaw herself trails us through her cabin and offers us a little bite to eat. (Gomez was pretty lucky with Meemaw’s selection; Lily not so much.) There’s also a moment of pure terror in the maze of animal pens when something that looks like a prop…isn’t. Because it’s Crawford, you can count on some thrilling jump scares in between the raunchy scenes.
You can opt to wear a glow necklace, which signals to the demons and deviants that you’re willing to be touched. Do so at your own risk. Crawford School of Terror works to ensure that this event engages ALL your senses. Over 18 Night is all in good fun, but this IS an extreme event. While I was waiting in line, I was kidnapped by two masked thugs. I was blindfolded, restrained, covered in silly string, and forced to sing for my freedom. When I was finally released, I stumbled into a crowd that was torn between slack-jawed horror and howling laughter.
The scene outside the schoolhouse adds to the party atmosphere. An elderly grandma and grandpa shuffle through the crowd, offering hard candy and advice while a weirdo in a latex romper offers treats of a different kind. Performers in fabulous outfits strut and twirl on a stage in the schoolyard while customers sip elaborate coffee drinks. The air vibrates with all the energy.
The entire event is a ridiculous rush, a no-holds-barred party for the end of spooky season. If you want something that’s freaky and fun, interactive and engaging, check out Crawford’s next Over 18 Night. It’s the kind of gleefully over-the-top creepy event that’s sure to gain a cult following.
Cost: $25 for general admission.
Safety Protocols, Group Size, Etc.: You’ll go through the haunt in groups of 5 to 6, working together. You have to sign a waiver, and you opt in to the more extreme elements of the attraction. Not everyone in our group chose the touch option, but we all got to interact with the monsters.
Concessions: Coffee at Crawford, the onsite coffee cart, was operating when we were there, serving themed coffees and other beverages. You can also get ice cream and other goodies..
Other Stuff To Do: A stage outside the school hosted a lively lip synch/drag show for people waiting in line. Crawford School of Terror has a pleasant fire pit, and a merch cart where you can browse the jewelry and vintage t-shirts.
Other Stuff To Know: When we say this is interactive, we mean it. Be prepared to be part of the show.