02/04/2021
By 1656, a tribe of Indians, numbering several hundred men, women, and children, thought to be from Pennsylvania or New York, traveled south and into Virginia. In the 1600s tribes frequently relocated to new areas if conditions changed where they lived. These Indians made their way to Richmond and settled in what’s now called Church Hill. This arrival prompted the Virginia Assembly to act and brought Totopotomoy, the weroance and war leader of the Pamunkey, into an alliance with the English to confront the outsiders. The migrated tribe would be considered a mutual enemy of Totopotomoy’s people and the English.
Totopotomoy brought 100 warriors to join with 100 Englishmen under Colonel Edward Hill, who commanded a force of militia from Charles City and Henrico Counties. These allied Virginians marched upon the fortified settlement of invading Indians who had journeyed from the far north and taken up a settlement atop what is now modern-day Church Hill or Chimborazo Hill. Although the Virginia Assembly ordered the English militia commander to “first endeavor to remove the said new come Indians without making war if it may be, only in a case of their own defense…” he had other plans.
Hill decided to ignore his orders and attempted to meet or kill the Indians leaders and then attack without negotiation. That plan failed to move the enemy from their positions. Hill then beat a hasty retreat to save his own life, thus leaving Totopotomoy and his warriors engaged alone. The Pamunkey warriors took on the invading natives without many English allies – being outnumbered perhaps two or three to one. The Pamunkey leader and warrior, with his men, went down fighting along the foot of modern-day Chimborazo Hill. All were slain in this battle known as “Bloody Run.”
The militia commander, Edward Hill, was eventually censured and punished by the Virginia Assembly for his poor handling of the events that day. Totopotomoy, the slain war leader and weroance of the Pamunkey, was replaced by his influential wife, Cockacoeske. She would famously lead the Pamunkey through the later 17th century and effectively bring the last collective treaties of several of the former “Powhatan Chiefdom” tribes into peace with the English, including the Treaty of Middle Plantation in 1677.