07/08/2026
🍦It’s a tough job, but someone had to do it. We spent time taste-testing our way through some of the most talked-about ice cream shops around town to find the absolute best scoop in St. Pete.
After plenty of sampling and zero regrets, one independent local favorite completely stood above the rest: Small Batch Creamery
Located on 4th Street North, this spot doesn’t do massive, mass-produced tubs. Instead, everything is made completely from scratch daily in tiny, precise quantities using local Florida milk, cream, and sugar cane with zero artificial additives or dyes.
The menu is massive, but we narrowed it down to our top 3 absolute must-try flavors, including a deep, intense coffee blend and a refreshing citrus scoop that tastes just like a gourmet pastry.
We want to hear from you: what is your absolute favorite ice cream flavor? Drop your go-to scoop in the comments! 👇
Want to know what to order on your first visit? Head to the blog to read our full review, find out more about the shop's unique history, and discover your next favorite scoop.