09/11/2026
With just 50 days until Halloween 2026, and just in time for your Friday commute - this could be the biggest trial of the decade... OK, year... OK maybe just this month but YOU, dear listeners, are the jury on appeal. Please share widely!
WEIGH IN THE COMMENTS! Tell us, once and for all...
If Die Hard is a Christmas movie π, does that mean E.T. the Extra-Terrestrial gets to be a Halloween movie π?
Meghan is taking the case to Holiday Movie Court. Halloween isn't just a random scene in E.T. β it's established early, becomes an important part of the film, and ultimately gives Elliott the perfect cover for getting a very conspicuous extraterrestrial out of the house and through a neighborhood full of trick-or-treaters.
So Meghan has a proposition: if the arguments used to admit Die Hard into the Christmas-movie club are applied consistently, E.T. has a case for admission as a Halloween movie.
There's just one complication. Lyle doesn't particularly like E.T., and he's been appointed the jury.
Meghan presents the evidence, Lyle delivers his verdict, and then the case goes to the court of public opinion. You are the jury on appeal. When you see this episode on our social media, tell us whether you uphold Lyle's verdict or overturn it β and give us your best argument for why.
If Die Hard is a Christmas movie, is E.T. a Halloween movie?
π§π Listen now wherever you get your podcasts π
https://www.thehalloweenpodcast.com/podcast/episode/1d17723e/is-et-a-halloween-movie-1982