09/28/2026
AITA for asking my brother and wife to vacate the basement? (r/AmItheAsshole)
I'm four years older than my brother, and we've always had a unique relationship. Growing up, my mother was unable to keep a job, so when I was 16, I quit high school and got a full-time job to provide for my mum and him.
When I started working, I took on the role of a father in a financial sense. I provided for his basic needs and gave him an allowance. He paid me back by being a great student and earning a full-ride scholarship abroad.
I'm 37 now, married, and have a decent quality of life. My brother got married too and just finished his master's degree, so they moved back to the city. He and his wife just started working but had no savings, so I offered to let them move into my basement for a year to save a little money and reconnect, as we haven't lived in the same city for over a decade.
They've been here for about four months now, and I feel disrespected and unappreciated in my own home. Here are a few scenarios:
1. At the beginning, I was super excited and tried to be hospitable. I cooked for them and tried to be a nice host, but they always complained about the food—it was never to their liking. I took them out for dinner: same story, not to their liking. I even took them on a trip, and from the hotels to the food, it was still not to their liking. However, my brother's wife has cooked a few times and cannot stop talking about how great their food is, asking us, "Aren't you happy that I'm here to cook for you?" But that's fine; people have different tastes.
2. They started criticizing things around my house, from the cleanliness (due to dog hair) to the brand of utensils and kitchenware we use. They even went so far as to ask me to throw away my stuff and use theirs instead.
3. I asked my brother to take turns cu***g the grass. He never did, and when I confronted him, he said he was too busy and tired.
4. I noticed my sister-in-law would not reply with a "hello" or "good morning" to my wife. I decided to talk to them, and my brother said that's just how she is, how she was raised, and that she has no filter.
I talked to them about all these issues, but their behavior didn't change, or they would say "good morning," "thanks," or "it's good" with a sarcastic tone.
I got upset and started doing the exact same things they did. Am I the A-hole for that? My brother complained and told me I was being rude toward him, and I explained that I was just mirroring them.
Now, my wife and I have talked, and we are going to ask them to move out in two months. AITA?