06/23/2026
Why did Jesus pick Peter to lead the Church instead of someone like ‘the beloved disciple,’ who seems to have a special closeness to Jesus?
While I will not claim to know Jesus’ mindset in choosing Peter as the “Rock” upon which He built the Church, I suspect that Peter was chosen because he had a special charism, a spiritual talent given by God for service.
Peter, the first pope, stands as a shining example of community leadership. From the first days of his discipleship, he seems to have naturally spoken as a representative for his fellow apostles. This is often what gets him in trouble — he says out loud what the others are afraid to!
Then, in the fullness of time, he acts as an institutional leader, serving on decision-making bodies such as the Council of Jerusalem (Acts 15) to bring discussion to a close and rally the whole Church around a chosen teaching.
We all have different charisms that are expressions of the Holy Spirit at work in us. These charisms do not make us better or worse, but they do suit us for particular types of ministry.
Read Father Schroeder's column: https://www.stlouisreview.com/story/dear-father-st-peter-is-an-example-of-embracing-our-charism/