11/01/2025
Did get to investigate Fox Hollow Farms once . It was a good investigation. Wish I had a few days & nights in a row to get more time there to explore . So much of the property we didn’t get to investigate.
Herb Baumeister seemed like a regular family man. The Indiana father of three ran a successful thrift store and lived with his wife and children on a vast estate in the suburbs of Indianapolis. But there were signs that something wasn't quite right with Herb Baumeister. Friends say he was a urophiliac who from an early age pondered "what it would be like to taste human urine." As an adult, Baumeister was fired from a job at the Bureau of Motor Vehicles after he was caught urinating on a letter addressed to the Indiana governor. He also made a number of business trips to Ohio during the 1980s — around the time a killer known as the "I-70 Strangler" began murdering gay men in Indianapolis and dumping their bodies along the interstate between Indiana and Ohio.
In 1994, Baumeister's young son found a human skull on the family's property. While Baumeister told his wife that the skeleton was part of an anatomical display that had belonged to his father, an anesthesiologist, she began to suspect her husband was hiding a dark secret — and two years later, police would find the remains of about a dozen men on their property.
Discover the chilling story of Herb Baumeister, the Indiana man suspected of killing about two dozen gay men and boys: https://inter.st/yv1m