09/10/2026
SHOOTING INVESTIGATION LEADS TO ARREST OF CONVICTED FELON WHO WAS RELEASED, THEN BACK IN JAIL THE NEXT DAY
What reportedly started as an argument Sunday evening ended with gunfire near a Lafayette home where children were reportedly present. Two days later, police had a suspect in custody, who is a convicted felon with a criminal history stretching back more than two decades. According to records, 47-year-old Andre Reeves was reportedly released the following morning, Sept 9th, 20226, and then landed right back in jail later that same day.
It started just before 7 p.m. Sunday, September 6, on N. 13th Street in Lafayette's Northside. According to information obtained, a caller reported witnessing the shooting. A witness told police the shooter may have used a revolver, and officers used surveillance cameras from the area as part of their investigation.
Just after 1 p.m. Tuesday, September 8, Lafayette Police had Reeves in custody. He was officially booked into the Tippecanoe County Jail at approximately 1:34 p.m.
The jail booking listed allegations of intimidation, criminal recklessness while armed with a deadly weapon, and unlawful carrying of a handgun.
But by the morning of September 9, according to information obtained, Reeves was already back out of jail, less than 24 hours after being booked following the shooting investigation.
That freedom didn't last very long for him, SURPRISED FACE.
Lafayette Police found Reeves in an alley behind the original caller's residence and took him into custody. Reeves was booked into the Tippecanoe County Jail again, this time on allegations of dealing in a controlled substance and invasion of privacy. The jail listing showed $2,500 cash / $25,000 surety associated with the dealing allegation.
Two bookings. Two consecutive days.
So, if you're wondering why his first release caught our attention, this wasn't Reeves' first trip through the criminal justice system. Not even close. Court records show Reeves' convictions stretch back to the 1990s.
In Lake County, Reeves was convicted of auto theft in cases dating back to 1998. In another Lake County case, Reeves was convicted of possession of co***ne and sentenced to 24 months in the Indiana Department of Correction.
Then came a 2005 case that is particularly relevant to his newest arrest. Reeves pleaded guilty to carrying a handgun without a license and possession of co***ne and received concurrent seven-year DOC sentences. The court dismissed other charges in that case.
His record continued in Tippecanoe County.
In 2009, Reeves was found guilty of dealing ma*****na, obstruction of justice, and operating while intoxicated, along with a habitual substance offender finding. The court imposed an aggregate 10-year sentence, with eight years ordered to be executed and two years suspended. That case later included additional community corrections and probation problems.
In 2013, Reeves pleaded guilty to failure to return to lawful detention as a Class D felony and was ordered to serve another 365 days, to be executed.
His criminal history continued into more recent years, including another Level 6 felony failure-to-return-to-lawful-detention conviction in Clinton County in 2020, for which he was sentenced to 182 days in jail.
So when Reeves was booked September 8 following this latest shooting investigation, this was not someone entering the criminal justice system for the first time. Court records establish Reeves as a multiple-time convicted felon with a previous handgun conviction and multiple prior prison sentences.
The first followed a shooting investigation and included allegations involving a deadly weapon and unlawful handgun possession. The second came after his release and included an allegation of dealing a controlled substance.
When your criminal history goes back to the 1990s, includes multiple felony convictions, a previous handgun conviction, and years in DOC, and you still manage to get booked twice in roughly 25 hours!
All current charges are allegations. Reeves is presumed innocent of the new charges unless and until proven guilty in court.