10/01/2026
STINES ASKS APPEALS COURT TO BLOCK SECOND MENTAL HEALTH EXAMINATION
Attorneys for former Letcher County Sheriff Shawn “Mickey” Stines are asking the Kentucky Court of Appeals to stop a second court-ordered mental health examination that is scheduled for Oct. 14.
In a petition filed Sept. 30, Stines’ lawyers argue he already underwent a criminal-responsibility evaluation through the Kentucky Correctional Psychiatric Center after prosecutors requested one. The defense says prosecutors have not identified any flaw or deficiency in that examination that would justify requiring Stines to submit to another interview.
Prosecutors later sought an additional examination by Indiana psychiatrist Dr. George Parker. Special Judge Christopher Cohron approved that request Aug. 11.
Stines’ attorneys argue a second compelled examination could violate his Fifth Amendment rights and potentially reveal defense strategy. They are asking the Court of Appeals to overturn Cohron’s order or, alternatively, limit prosecutors to having another expert review the existing KCPC report and related records without conducting another interview.
The defense also filed an emergency motion seeking to block the Oct. 14 examination while the appeals court considers the case.
Stines, seen in the photo accompanying this report, is charged with murder in the September 2024 shooting death of Letcher District Judge Kevin Mullins inside Mullins’ chambers at the Letcher County Courthouse.
The Court of Appeals had not ruled on either request as of the filing.
The Mountain Eagle will continue to follow the case as new court filings and rulings become available.