04/10/2026
The restaurant we really didn’t want to like this much.
If you remember Joe’s Rum Hut in Cruz Bay, you’ll probably understand why.
We LOVED that place. The laid-back vibe, sunset views, and those braised short ribs kept us coming back trip after trip. So when it closed and eventually became Karma Beach Lounge, we were a little salty about it. 🤣
Then Karma opened in 2025…and we started seeing some pretty mixed reviews.
So naturally, we waited.
We finally decided to give it a try in October 2025, fully prepared for it to be one-and-done.
Well…we were wrong.
Since that first visit, we’ve been back every time we visit St. John for lunch, dinner, drinks, and sometimes simply because we start craving their sushi.
And now? It’s genuinely become one of our favorite places to eat in Cruz Bay.
We love the sushi, the waterfront setting is hard to beat, and it still gives us that relaxed “we’re on St. John” feeling we loved so much about this spot before.
Do we still miss Joe’s Rum Hut? Absolutely.
But we also have to give Karma credit for winning over two people who were pretty determined not to like it. 😂
And that’s exactly why we always say: reviews can be helpful, but sometimes you just have to try a place for yourself.
Have you tried Karma yet? I’m curious—what did you think? 👇