Grocott's Mail

Grocott's Mail News and information about Makhanda and surrounds - what makes our town and surrounds tick, and what ticks our residents off.

Grocott's Mail has remained independent for 155 years. We ask that all users follow the following Community Guidelines:
- Be respectful to all those with whom you interact within our social media communities.
- Share your comments and ideas thoughtfully, with the consideration you would expect to be afforded.
- Refrain from inappropriate, off-topic, abusive, harassing, or profane comments.
- Do no

t post information that would be considered spam or use our platforms to promote/solicit visits to third-party sites, initiatives or products.
- Refrain from soliciting business or requesting donations.
- We reserve the right to reject or remove comments that are not in keeping with our policy, values, and principles; and to block or ban users/followers who do not follow these guidelines.
- The guidelines apply to all Grocott’s Mail social media channels available. Categories of comments we will respond to:
- Violence and criminal behaviour (threatening others, revealing private information about others, hateful speech pertaining to race/ ethnicity/ religion /sexual orientation/ swear words regardless of the language)
- Safety (e.g. su***de and self-harm or injury, child sexual exploitation, abuse, nudity; adult sexual exploitation, bullying and harassment, human exploitation and privacy violations)
- Objectionable content (e.g. hate speech, violent and graphic content, adult nudity and sexual activity, sexual solicitation)
Integrity and authenticity (cyber security concerns, spam, misinformation and fake news)


Here on we share breaking news, information and the best stories published on https://grocotts.ru.ac.za plus the weekly PDF edition of GMDirect. Other ways to stay in touch:
GMD Direct on Fridays (weekly PDF edition only) http://bit.ly/GMDirectWA
GMD Live ( weekly PDF edition plus daily news and information updates) http://bit.ly/GMLiveWA
GMDirect by email: www.grocotts.co.za click on SIGN UP FOR OUR NEWSLETTER
MINI-ARCHIVE: Read the past 20 editions here: http://bit.ly/GMDirectMC

Write to:
Letters: [email protected]
Whats On: [email protected]
Advertising: [email protected]
Newsroom and Production: [email protected]

Exhibition showcases books banned by apartheid-era censorsBy Gcina NtsalubaBooks that were banned during South Africa's ...
18/10/2025

Exhibition showcases books banned by apartheid-era censors

By Gcina Ntsaluba

Books that were banned during South Africa's apartheid era are now on display at Rhodes University Main Library, offering students and the public a glimpse into one of the darkest chapters of the country's censorship history.

According to Wynand van der Walt, senior manager for innovation, systems and collections at the
university's library, the exhibition represents a small portion of the more than 26 000 titles listed in Jacobsen's Index of Objectionable Literature, a comprehensive catalogue of materials the apartheid state sought to suppress.

"These books were banned not for lacking literary merit, but for being perceived as threats to the state," explained Van der Walt, who worked at the Transvaal Provincial Library Services during the transition to democracy, He said that the censorship apparatus was maintained through an interlocking web of legislation, primarily the Customs Act of 1955 and the Publications Act of 1974, which gave authorities sweeping powers to declare publications "undesirable".

The banned collection included political writings by African National Congress leaders, works by prominent South African authors such as Alex la Guma, Bessie Head, and André Brink, as well as international classics like George Orwell's Animal Farm and Nineteen Eighty-Four.

A gradual return

Van der Walt said that the return of these books was a gradual process rather than a single event. While the government of F.W. de Klerk unbanned political organisations like the ANC on 2 February 1990, the formal Publications Act remained in force until the transition to democracy.

"The legal right to possess these books existed almost immediately after the repeal of the old laws, but their presence in libraries and bookstores was not instantaneous," he said. The full process of reintegration extended throughout the late 1990s and into the 2000s.

Many academic libraries, including Rhodes University, had maintained closed collections where banned books were held with restricted access, often requiring special permission for research purposes. Once the laws changed, these materials were released onto open shelves.

Some lost forever

Van der Walt said that some books proved difficult to find even after being unbanned, with certain editions and original manuscripts lost forever due to systematic destruction during the apartheid years.

"Even today, original printings or specific ephemeral materials from the ban period remain extremely rare and are highly prized by collectors and archives," he said.

The library continues actively sourcing materials, recently acquiring a copy of Stanley Bekker en die boikot by John Miles which, in 1981, was the first Afrikaans children's book to be banned. It is now housed at the Cory Library for Humanities Research.

Timely reminder

Van der Walt's engagement with the exhibition was prompted by Advocate Shuaib Rahim from the Faculty of Law, who reminded him of this period in South African history. The timing coincided with International Banned Books Week (5-11 October 2025), promoted by the American Library Association and Amnesty International.

"The international political landscape keeps reminding me that we should never take our rights for granted," Van der Walt said, noting that censorship is not limited to authoritarian regimes. During 2024-2025, more than 6 870 instances of book banning have occurred across 23 states in the United States.

Why ideas are dangerous

Reflecting on why the apartheid regime found these books so threatening, Van der Walt explained: "Ideas are dangerous to authoritarian regimes because they possess the capacity to inform and sway support. These alternative ideas unify, motivate, and legitimise resistance, directly challenging the regime's control over the public mind."

He emphasised the importance of students and researchers understanding this history: "Intellectual curiosity and the pursuit of diverse knowledge are not merely academic exercises but essential acts of citizenship that protect democracy."

Van der Walt said that adequate representation of suppressed voices requires systematic curriculum revision, dedicated funding for preservation and digitisation, and active enforcement of constitutional rights to freedom of expression and access to information.

The exhibition serves as both a historical record and a contemporary warning that intellectual freedom must be constantly defended.

Wool warriors knit to help and to healBy Olwethu Wessels Something is happening in a cosy lounge inside Settlers Close r...
18/10/2025

Wool warriors knit to help and to heal

By Olwethu Wessels

Something is happening in a cosy lounge inside Settlers Close retirement home, and it involves baskets of wool, knitting needles on the go and an important mission.

It was hot outside the day Grocott’s Mail called but this room oozed extra warmth – from the spirit of the women who gather there to knit. Lines of Father Christmas dolls are ready for seasonal duty. Vibrant blues, pinks, reds, and greens spill from wool baskets. But there’s serious purpose to the other dolls that roll off the knitters’ needles.

For young children who have experienced abuse in any way, soft toys can both comfort and heal. Audrey van Aardt’s son, Martin, a retired police officer who is passionate about his work with children who have experienced abuse, had the idea first. “When Martin told us about what these kids go through, it broke our hearts,” Van Aardt said. “He explained how a doll could be more than a toy. It could become something to hold onto, something that gives comfort when everything else has been taken away, and we were glad that he brought this idea to us.” The women set about knitting for the SAPS Family Violence, Child Protection and Sexual Offenses (FCS) unit.

It can take years for police to arrest a perpetrator by which time a child’s doll is worn out. These women knit them another one.

But the healing is not one-way.

The project has been a source of connection and renewed purpose for the warriors with wool. Mariette Steyn and Diann Bates, who lost their life partners, were navigating the grief that can come with retirement. “We were down and out,” Steyn said. Until they started knitting again, giving them a reason to smile and laugh, and a purpose.

The knitting room is always buzzing, filled with teasing, storytelling, and shared joy. Knitting also keeps their minds active and hands busy – even for those struggling with poor eyesight. “We’ve got bad eyesight, but that’s no excuse,” Van Aardt said.

According to Bates, who enjoys experimenting with colours and styles, “Mariette talks to her dolls before they leave. Sometimes she even gives them names! I’m not heartsore when the dolls go. I’m just excited they’re finally leaving because I know a child’s going to be so happy.

“We even sew little hearts on the dolls,” Bates added. “It’s our way of sending love so the kids can see it and feel it.”

Project manager Steyn said, “We laugh a lot here. It’s a sad topic, but this project brings us joy. It brings us together. We would do anything for kids.”

The first batch of dolls went to children in Riebeeck East, a memory which still makes the knitters emotional. “They were so happy because they didn’t expect it – it’s nice to receive something unexpectedly,” Van Aardt said. During a recent handover, the Port Alfred and Makhanda FCS units came to Settlers Close to collect two full boxes of teddies, beanies and even a blanket for child victims. The FCS team, Captain Sangotsha, Warrant Officer Mafani, and Constable Sandra Catherine, shared stories and heartfelt thanks with their allies.

“We know SAPS gets a lot of criticism,” Van Aardt said. “But after seeing how they work with these kids – we realise it’s hard and they’re doing their best. They care.”

Meanwhile, the women of Settlers Close also raise funds and solicit donations of wool. “I wish more people would catch onto this,” said Van Aardt. “It should be like the flu – contagious kindness.”

What would these women like to say to the children receiving their dolls? Steyn pauses. “I wish I could take all the hurt away. They’re all in our hearts.”

Photos: Supplied

'I was treated like a hardcore criminal'By Phila-Nathi MapisaLuyanda Sakata, chairperson of Grahamstown Anti-Crime group...
17/10/2025

'I was treated like a hardcore criminal'

By Phila-Nathi Mapisa

Luyanda Sakata, chairperson of Grahamstown Anti-Crime group, walked out of the Makhanda Magistrate's Court a free man on Tuesday after the court delivered a Section 174 verdict, finding insufficient evidence to proceed with murder charges against him.

The case brings closure to a harrowing 19-month ordeal that saw the community activist spend three months behind bars for a crime he maintains he never committed – the murder of a man he says he had never even seen before.

A shocking arrest

"I was so shocked when I faced murder charges of a person I had never even seen before," Sakata told Grocott's Mail in an exclusive interview alongside his attorney, Mfundo Ntshwaxa.

"Having multiple police vans, police officers with torches terrorising your home with your children and partner at 5am is traumatising," Sakata recounted. "I felt that I was treated like a hardcore criminal, more so as an innocent man."

Three months behind bars

After the Magistrate's Court denied him bail, Sakata spent three months in prison before the High Court granted his bail appeal on 24 March 2024. The conditions were harsh and degrading: sleeping on cement floors, enduring periods without water, and sharing cells with the very criminals his anti-crime initiative had helped put away.

"I couldn't sleep at night and tried to take naps during the day as I was truly so fearful for my life," Sakata said. "I truly believe that there was a plot against me to get me in prison and leave me to die there."

The legal battle

The case moved through the courts with trial dates set for 30 September and 1 and 3 October 2025. However, on 15 October 2025, the magistrate delivered a Section 174 verdict of the Criminal Procedure Act, finding that there was insufficient evidence to sustain the charges.

Attorney Mfundo Ntshwaxa, who represented Sakata pro bono, explained his motivation for taking the case: "I wanted to assist Sakata. I admire the work they do in the community and in my capacity wanted to help him. I have lived experiences of the anti-crime group being of great assistance when I and local schools needed their help."

Ntshwaxa worked alongside Advocate Lutho Jolobe and the entire legal team to secure Sakata's freedom.

No winners in this case

Despite the acquittal, both Sakata and Ntshwaxa emphasised a sad reality. "Although they were acquitted of these charges and they are dropped, there is no winner in cases like these, because at the end of the day someone is dead and the killer is unknown because due diligence was never done," Ntshwaxa said.

Mending fractured relationships

Sakata revealed that his relationship with Joza Police Station, once collaborative and productive, had deteriorated prior to his arrest. "I never knew that the deterioration of my relationship with Joza SAPS would have led to such," he said.

He disclosed that the anti-crime group had raised grievances about Colonel Nomsa Mtshagi with the Eastern Cape Department of Community Safety's District Manager for Sarah Baartman District, Mncedisi Boma. However, Sakata says efforts have since been made to cultivate and mend the relationship between the anti-crime group and the police station.

The fear of a criminal record

Beyond the physical hardships of imprisonment, Sakata feared the permanent stigma of a criminal record. "I hated the prospect of having a criminal record. Despite the terrible stigma it holds, it would interfere with the good I'm trying to do," he said.

Community support

Throughout his ordeal, it was the community that sustained Sakata. From prison visits to monetary contributions for bail and legal fees, from public support to simply standing by him, the community rallied around their leader.

"I have unwavering thanks to the community that stood by me, the visits in prison, the monetary contributions to pay for bail and legal fees for the advocate, the support, looking out for me," Sakata said with emotion.

This outpouring of support is what keeps him committed to his work, despite the challenges he has faced. "It's the community that stood by me that makes me not ever want to quit this work of activism that I'm doing, despite all these challenges. Sisebenzela abantu abasweleyo," he said.

Makhanda school's learners shine at annual awardsBy Luvuyo MjekulaSamuel Ntsiko Primary School learners walked away with...
17/10/2025

Makhanda school's learners shine at annual awards

By Luvuyo Mjekula

Samuel Ntsiko Primary School learners walked away with medals, certificates and other accolades at the school’s annual prize-giving on Friday, 17 October.

The event at the Foley’s Community Hall in Hlalani Location celebrated the learners' achievements in academics, sports and other disciplines.

Grade 7 learner Emma Jena was the top achiever, winning Ikhakha - The Best Learner Award, for the second year in a row.

According to the school’s eligibility criteria, the learner who wins Ikhakha possesses many positive attributes.

The award acknowledges academic excellence, resilience and exceptional performance in all subjects.

The learner has a strong work ethic, thinks critically, communicates effectively, has respect and adaptability to overcome challenges. The learner has genuine interest in learning new things and passion for discovery.

Other qualities include an ability to analyse information and solve problems as well as bounce back from setbacks and persevere through difficult times.

Thirteen-year-old Jena said she was surprised to win the award for the second time. However, she was very happy to win in front of her family members.

Her mother Rachel Jena and aunt Vongai Rwanga were proud of her achievements.

We all have the same humanity. By Ongeziwe SigwebelaProfessor Franklin Larey, the Director of the School of Music at Bal...
17/10/2025

We all have the same humanity.

By Ongeziwe Sigwebela

Professor Franklin Larey, the Director of the School of Music at Ball State University in Indiana, United States, was recently honoured for his lifelong contribution to music and education. Rhodes University awarded him an Honorary Doctor of Music last Friday, making him the only recipient to be honoured on the day.

Originally from South Africa, Professor Larey expressed deep pride and gratitude upon receiving the recognition, calling it “an immense honour” for the work he has done both locally and internationally.

Larey says music is more than a sound; it is a bridge between people, culture, and dreams.

Larey highlighted the importance of making music education accessible to all children, especially those in rural areas. “My message to everybody is to make this kind of education, or any education, accessible to everybody,” he said. He emphasised that education should be grounded in social justice, equity, and opportunity, ensuring that talented young people are not left behind due to a lack of access or resources.

Although he is currently based in the United States, Larey said that he hopes to return to South Africa, “My promise and my plans are to return after retirement and make further contributions to developing talents and giving opportunities to very many young people,” he said.

His dedication to nurturing the next generation of musicians continues to inspire both students and educators.

When asked about the differences between teaching music in South Africa and the United States,
Larey said that there are “very few differences.” He explained that students in both countries
share the same passion and drive to succeed. “We all have the same humanity,” he said, “We deal with
young people who have the same aspirations. Nothing gave me more pleasure than to see everybody
working so hard and wanting the same thing.”

For Larey, music is not only about performance but also about personal expression and connection. He believes musicians reach their most authentic selves when they perform. “We find our deepest being actually very vulnerable at that moment because we express our very deepest emotions,” he said.

Through his lifelong commitment to teaching and his vision for inclusive music education, Professor
Larey continues to inspire hope, creativity, and unity across the continents, a legacy that now carries the
distinguished recognition of Rhodes University’s Honorary Doctorate in Music.

Photo: Professor Franklin Larey.

It is a homecoming for me. By Sindisiwe TshonaIn a ceremony brimming with a sense of homecoming and historic transition,...
17/10/2025

It is a homecoming for me.

By Sindisiwe Tshona

In a ceremony brimming with a sense of homecoming and historic transition, Rhodes University celebrated the installation of Justice Mbuyiseli Madlanga as its eighth Chancellor, succeeding Justice Lex Mpati.

The 2025 Spring Graduation ceremony was described by Vice-Chancellor Professor Sizwe Mabizela as a “tremendous day” and a “fresh beginning” for the institution. He highlighted the significance of appointing an alumnus and a son of the Eastern Cape, saying, “We could not have selected a better person… He will build on a very strong foundation but will also chart his own course.”

For Justice Madlanga, the appointment was deeply personal. “It’s both humbling and heartwarming, especially because this is my alma mater,” he said in an interview with Grocott's Mail. “So in a sense, it is a homecoming for me.” He follows in the footsteps of a man he affectionately calls “Bhuti Lex".

In his inaugural address, “Rhodes University: Where Leaders Learn,” the new Chancellor outlined a vision of servant leadership, strategic guidance, and a steadfast commitment to accessibility. He pledged to be a champion for the disadvantaged, emphasising that “one would not like to see talented students being denied access to education purely because of their circumstances.”

He pointed to the resilience of the university community in the face of Makhanda’s water crisis as a real-world example of leadership, where intellect and empathy combine to transform adversity into innovation. “When graduates leave Rhodes and Makhanda, they carry with them more than a degree,” he said, “They carry the lessons of resilience learned in seasons of trial… and a moral compass shaped by community.”

Looking ahead, Justice Madlanga committed to a Rhodes University that is a “model of what a deeply rooted, forward-looking African university can be.” His strategic priorities include strengthening excellence with equity, deepening research impact on societal challenges like youth unemployment and climate change, and nurturing a culture of entrepreneurial thinking.

“My promise is simple,” he concluded, “to listen before I speak, to serve before I lead, and to work with all who share the belief that knowledge and conscience belong together,” Madlanga said.

Photo one caption: Chancellor Justice Mbuyiseli Madlanga
Photo two caption: Vice-Chancellor Professor Sizwe Mabizela
Photo three caption: Graduation ceremony.

Taxi strike ends after successful negotiations. By Phila-Nathi MapisaA Scholar Transport strike that affected learners i...
17/10/2025

Taxi strike ends after successful negotiations.

By Phila-Nathi Mapisa

A Scholar Transport strike that affected learners in Makana has been resolved following a meeting between Premier Oscar Mabuyane and the South African National Taxi Council (Santaco) yesterday.

Unathi Binqose, spokesperson for the Eastern Cape Department of Transport, confirmed that the meeting went well. "We agreed that the strike is over and we've reached a resolution," he said.

Songezo Mpanda, spokesperson for Santaco Eastern Cape, confirmed that the Scholar Transport services are operating today. He said they expect to receive payments next week and have made arrangements for regular meetings with the MEC of Transport, Xolile Nqatha, to avoid similar build-ups and unhappiness in the future.

Background

The strike began earlier this week as a result of the Department of Transport's failure to pay for services rendered to taxi associations, according to Maarsdorp Cannon, the district official responsible for Scholar Transport.

A member of the Border Alliance Taxi Association, one of the contracted Scholar Transport services, said their organisation had been receiving payments in the districts where they operate but was striking in solidarity with colleagues who had not been paid.

During the strike matric pupils continued to be transported to school to prepare for their final exams. "We have no intention to punish the learners in this strike but are trying to make the department aware of our grievances," Mpanda had said earlier this week.

Department's response

Prior to the resolution, Binqose had explained that the payment delays happened because the department needed to ensure that claims and invoices were accurate, all supporting documents were present and that services were actually rendered.

He said: "We will take accountability and admit that we have had issues with our systems. Binqose emphasised that the department remains committed to ensuring that people receive their payments but wants the community to understand that taxpayers' money must be used with caution and wisdom.

"Our strict systems in screening invoices and all necessary paperwork are to avoid taxpayers' money being used wrongfully, and we need to ensure that services were actually rendered," he said.

My work has always been about the students. By Sindisiwe TshonaThe Spring Graduation was a heartfelt farewell to the uni...
17/10/2025

My work has always been about the students.

By Sindisiwe Tshona

The Spring Graduation was a heartfelt farewell to the university's icon, Desiree Wicks, who received a rousing standing ovation not once, but twice, in recognition of her four decades of service.

Professor Mabokang Monnapula-Mapasela, Deputy Vice-Chancellor for Academic and Student Affairs, announced that Wicks was the recipient of the Vice-Chancellor’s Distinguished Achievement Award. The honour recognised her “unwavering compassion, leadership, and tireless dedication to the holistic development of Rhodes University students.”

For 40 years, Wicks was a cornerstone of student support, championing access and ensuring that “thousands of students from all backgrounds, regardless of race, class, or status, were guided, mentored, and empowered throughout their academic journeys.”

Her commitment to uplifting others has left an “indelible mark on this institution,” Prof Monnapula-Mapasela said. To ensure her legacy of compassion continues, the University announced the launch of an annual golf day in 2026. The initiative, led by the Student Services and Development Division and the Sports Council, will raise funds to support students facing socioeconomic challenges.

In an interview with Grocott's Mail, Wicks said, "I am honoured to be recognised in such a way. My work has always been about the students, and I was completely overwhelmed by the kindness of people."

As she steps into a well-deserved retirement, the thunderous applause that echoes through the hall serves as a powerful testament to a career defined by the profound and lasting impact she has had on generations of students.

Photo caption: Desiree Wicks

Bongeziwe Mabandla coming to Makhanda.  By Nomfundo MbathaSouth Africa's "spiritual Afro-folk" musician, Bongeziwe Maban...
17/10/2025

Bongeziwe Mabandla coming to Makhanda.

By Nomfundo Mbatha

South Africa's "spiritual Afro-folk" musician, Bongeziwe Mabandla, is bringing his soulful and spiritual presence to the Stage of Makhanda for a one-night show. Tomorrow, Mabandla will perform live at The Black Power Station, marking one of the most anticipated stops on his Solo Tour running from October 18–25.

With his unique voice and deeply introspective lyrics, Mabandla has carved out a distinct niche in South African music, one that combines Xhosa storytelling with soulful melodies and contemporary production. His songs transcend genre and language, speaking to something deeply human: love, identity, and spiritual connection.

With nothing but his guitar and his poetic sound, people could expect a sensational experience and connect to his music. Tickets may be purchased through this link: https://www.quicket.co.za/events/338178-bongeziwe-mabandla-solo-tour-live-in-makhanda/?ref=organiser-profile #/

Photo caption: IsiXhosa folk and soul singer-songwriter Bongeziwe Mabandla performed at the 1820 Settlers Monument on his amaXesha tour. Photo: Buhle Andisiwe Made

Last resort' court action on animals. By Staff ReporterThe Makana Business Residents Association (MBRA) has turned to th...
17/10/2025

Last resort' court action on animals.

By Staff Reporter

The Makana Business Residents Association (MBRA) has turned to the High Court as a "last resort" to compel Makana Municipality to address the persistent issue of stray livestock roaming urban areas. This follows unsuccessful engagements with officials since January 2025.

In its founding affidavit, the MBRA demands that the Municipal Manager and Executive Mayor submit a report within 30 days detailing steps taken to enforce bylaws on animal control. It also seeks a timeline for establishing a functional animal pound and proper management of municipal commonages and open spaces.

Additionally, the group requests:

Names of all users of commonages, public open spaces, and municipal farms;
A full inventory of animals grazing there;
Records of grazing fees and rentals collected over the past five years;
Details of veterinary tests on stock, including results from the last five years;
A report on the condition of boundary fences around these properties.

Background in the affidavit reveals that the municipality's commonage has grown from 3,370 hectares in the early 2000s to 11,578 hectares today, primarily to support emerging farmers. Its estimated carrying capacity is 1,862 large stock units (a standard measure equating to one cow or five sheep).

Despite assistance from Rhodes University, the Agricultural Research Council, and others since 2005, the affidavit claims no progress, attributing the problem to a small group monopolising the land with alleged municipal consent. It notes that no rental income was recorded for the commonage for at least 10 years.

The affidavit records that at an ordinary council meeting on 30 October 2019, it was made known that the lease agreements with the emerging farmers had lapsed and that the municipality was considering a new kind of lease arrangement with an association rather than individual farmers, which was thought to be more beneficial.

The affidavit points out that the failure to control animal roaming was one of the issues cited in the application to the High Court to dissolve the municipality in 2019.

The document also records numerous letters to and engagements with the municipality this year, attempting to get action on the issue and to avoid legal action. Among them:

On 13 January, a letter was sent on behalf of the Makana Unity League, the Business Forum and the Residents' Association to the Municipal Manager and Executive Mayor, urging them to deal with the situation. Although the municipality responded with an "action plan", the situation did not improve.
In May this year, the head of Graeme College wrote to the Municipal Manager about an aggressive bull found on a playing field and cattle dung posing a health hazard.
Then, in June, responding to a report in the Daily Maverick about foot and mouth disease and no improvement in the situation, a letter was sent asking for an urgent meeting, which was held with the Parks and Recreation Department.
In July, further letters and attempts were made by the municipality to identify land for a pound and to review what the municipality called "the antiquated legislative framework governing animal impoundment".

The affidavit cites harms like injuries to people and animals, property damage, graveyard desecration, and risks at the airfield and schools. It echoes concerns from a 2019 court bid to dissolve the municipality.

MBRA chair Marcus Mostert called the action a "last resort" after exhausting other remedies, seeking a court-supervised order. The municipality did not respond to requests for comment by publication time. The case could set a precedent for rural-urban livestock management in South Africa, with a hearing date pending.

Photo caption: supplied by The Makana Business Residents Association page.

Community halls abandoned and neglected. By Nomfundo Mbatha and Malebo PhemeCommunity halls across Makhanda and Alicedal...
17/10/2025

Community halls abandoned and neglected.

By Nomfundo Mbatha and Malebo Pheme

Community halls across Makhanda and Alicedale have been neglected and mismanaged. Four key halls, kwaNonzwakazi Hall, Transriviere Community Hall, Tantyi Hall, and Luvuyo Hall are now abandoned by their communities. These spaces, intended as gathering points for community events, have fallen into disrepair, affected by broken fences, shattered windows, vandalism, and growing mountains of waste.

Security is compromised at all four locations, and the absence of regular maintenance has made the stairways impractical for use. Luvuyo Hall, in particular, had become a dumping ground both inside and outside the premises, underscoring the extent of the building’s decline.

Yet, amidst the decay, the Social Employment Fund, supported by the National Arts Festival, has managed to turn Luvuyo Hall into something of value. The hall is now home to the SEF recycling initiative. According to Luvolwethu Mzalazala, the SEF team leader, the project team has worked hard to keep the hall clean and functional without any support from the municipality. Mzalazala said that municipal officials have never visited the site. The ward councillor makes occasional checks, but there have been no formal comments on the hall’s condition.

Unlike Luvuyo Hall, which is in use, kwaNonzwakazi Hall in Alicedale has been left to fall apart. The hall is accessible only through a broken fence, with doors and windows completely damaged. Inside, the hall is in a state of chaos, showing clear signs of neglect.

According to local residents, the hall has been closed for some time due to mismanagement. The individual who was in charge of the project misused funds and failed to complete the necessary repairs.

This closure has created significant challenges for the community because the hall was used to hold funeral services, but now the community is forced to rent the town hall, which is far from their homes and comes with additional costs.

One resident said elderly people, who would normally walk to the local hall, now have to pay for transport or walk long distances to the town hall. The Town Hall, too, is in poor condition. Some toilets don't work, and there are ongoing water issues. Leaks, broken windows, and a lack of cleaning supplies further complicate its use.

“It’s difficult to keep the place going,” one local said. “We don’t have the right tools to clean, and the hall is constantly in need of repairs. It’s frustrating.”

The situation in Makhanda mirrors that of Alicedale, with many public halls in the area suffering from the same problems: broken doors, windows, poor sanitation, and a general lack of care. The municipality has offered little to no support, leaving these spaces abandoned and unusable.

For communities in Alicedale and Makhanda, the loss of these halls has created a ripple effect. Essential services like funerals, community meetings, and other events are affected. Without local spaces to meet, community life is impacted negatively.

Makana Municipality had not responded in time for publication.

Photos by: Asemahle Vumsindo

Address

Africa Media Matrix, Prince Alfred Street
Grahamstown
6139

Opening Hours

Monday 08:30 - 16:30
Tuesday 08:00 - 16:30
Wednesday 08:00 - 16:30
Thursday 08:00 - 16:30
Friday 08:00 - 16:30
Saturday 08:30 - 12:00

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Grocott's Mail posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Grocott's Mail:

Share

The good, the bad... and the beautiful

Grocott's Mail and Grocott’s Live bring you the best and worst of what happens in and around Grahamstown... and everything in between! Still independent after 147 years, serving the town with a mind of its own.