05/19/2026
🛩️ Tin Goose Diner — Honest Review (Ohio)
We stopped in at the Tin Goose Diner after hearing they had the best milkshakes in Ohio. Here's my straight-up take:
The Milkshake ($8): It was okay. Not worth $8. You can get a better milkshake at McDonald's, Five Guys, or literally any local ice cream shop for the same price or less.
Cranberry Chicken Salad Croissant ($10 — no side): The menu calls it "piled high" and homemade. What showed up was a thin smear of what looked like processed chicken salad from a food supplier with craisins tossed in to dress it up. Not homemade. For $10 with zero side dish, this is a $6-7 sandwich at best.
Large Fries ($6): Barely a half serving. Looked like a child's portion. Under-seasoned and forgettable.
The one thing I WILL recommend: If the weather is nice, go grab a milkshake or malt and sit outside on the patio to watch the planes take off and land. That experience is genuinely fun and worth the trip.
But if you're going for the food expecting great value or homemade quality — skip it. Your money goes a lot further elsewhere.
Drop a comment if you've been — did you have the same experience?